Lok Sabha passes Citizenship Bill amidst Opposition outcry

CAA is perfect as it specifies the religion only for three countries. Muslims even from these countries and also from everyother are still allowed following the normal naturalisation process. CAA only gives priority for the non muslims of these countries. It does not exclude muslims per se.

What exactly did it accomplish except create an open fight and rioting situation?
 
This rioting is not due to CAA alone. It is a cumulative effect of Muslims losing everywhere from Triple Talak, to 370 to Ram Janam Bhoomi to NRC in Assam. They had been nurturing it and CAA gave them a reason to riot.

no major protests took place on triple talak or even RJB. It was only when an explicitly discriminatory law was passed that they protested. It is a fact.
 
no major protests took place on triple talak or even RJB. It was only when an explicitly discriminatory law was passed that they protested. It is a fact.

The modus operandi has changed. They are now sabotaging system where they can't do halla gulla other places you can read the news , in WB a hand made grenade was thrown over DCP. This is terrorism.
 
no major protests took place on triple talak or even RJB. It was only when an explicitly discriminatory law was passed that they protested. It is a fact.
Did u hear that Keralite jihadeen from Jamia in that Barkas interview. She said after RJB we dont have faith on SC , we were silent on Kashmir bkah blah
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlackOpsIndia
This rioting is not due to CAA alone. It is a cumulative effect of Muslims losing everywhere from Triple Talak, to 370 to Ram Janam Bhoomi to NRC in Assam. They had been nurturing it and CAA gave them a reason to riot.
More than that it is fear... even that video asking muslm rioters as to the reason of their protest, has many of them talking about NRC. They rightly realize that the NRC holds a gun to their head, and with the final recourse of declaring themselves as refugees not available to muslims, they are running riot. They are trying to stop the NRC, before the long night consumes them. It's not about sheltering some Muslim fu**Kers from Bangladesh or Pakistan, that they are agitating about. It's about their own future that they are worried.
 
So Pakistan presented an example of Muslims that may need accomodation in CAA by handing death sentence to hubul watan Gen Pervez Musharraf.

You dumb Hindu Baniya never saw it coming. This proves rioters and protesters have more wisdom than lawmakers and Indian parliament.

Take that e.ndia.
 
More than that it is fear... even that video asking muslm rioters as to the reason of their protest, has many of them talking about NRC. They rightly realize that the NRC holds a gun to their head, and with the final recourse of declaring themselves as refugees not available to muslims, they are running riot. They are trying to stop the NRC, before the long night consumes them. It's not about sheltering some Muslim fu**Kers from Bangladesh or Pakistan, that they are agitating about. It's about their own future that they are worried.
Indian muslims do not have reason to denounce CAA or NRC. But the reality is that Indian muslims are hidden wahabis like the Pakistani sunni muslims. They want Rohingyas and BD muslims to be given citizenship as well. It is this which is the root cause of all the rioting. They fear losing WB completely which they have tried to convert to an Islamic state like J&K. 370 killed the hegemony of muslims in J&K, NRC and CAA will do the same to Bihar, WB, Assam and other states in NE. Muslims in India suddenly find their 70 yr dream broken by MSD.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Nikhil and Ironhide
Indian muslims do not have reason to denounce CAA or NRC. But the reality is that Indian muslims are hidden wahabis like the Pakistani sunni muslims. They want Rohingyas and BD muslims to be given citizenship as well. It is this which is the root cause of all the rioting. They fear losing WB completely which they have tried to convert to an Islamic state like J&K. 370 killed the hegemony of muslims in J&K, NRC and CAA will do the same to Bihar, WB, Assam and other states in NE. Muslims in India suddenly find their 70 yr dream broken by MSD.

Modi never had a reason to create a discriminatory law. He could have passed a non discriminatory law and then made sure that only Hindus got acceptance.....but that would not have let him achieve the division he was planning and protests that would take attention away from his enormous failure as a PM. If India was growing at 12% a year you think he would have done this? He would have tomtommed that no end. Now because he is a failure he needs to rile up on all these issues.
 
Modi never had a reason to create a discriminatory law. He could have passed a non discriminatory law and then made sure that only Hindus got acceptance.....but that would not have let him achieve the division he was planning and protests that would take attention away from his enormous failure as a PM. If India was growing at 12% a year you think he would have done this? He would have tomtommed that no end. Now because he is a failure he needs to rile up on all these issues.
One of the biggest thing which most of you have failed to notice is the slogans they shouted and their comments about SC. They hold SC gulty of hanging Afzal Guru and Yakub Memon. They also hold SC guilty of giving RJB to Hindus. Can you please explain what have hindus done which calls for their Kabr to be built in AMU? And how can you stay in India if you do not accept the verdict of SC? The truth my friend is very clear for everyone to see. What Islam could not achieve since 622AD is still the main agenda of these people. They want to convert or kill every Hindu and make India an Islamic republic. Wherever Islam went, they converted or killed the entire population. India and its majority Hindu population remains a sore point for them.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Nikhil and Ironhide
One of the biggest thing which most of you have failed to notice is the slogans they shouted and their comments about SC. They hold SC gulty of hanging Afzal Guru and Yakub Memon. They also hold SC guilty of giving RJB to Hindus. Can you please explain what have hindus done which calls for their Kabr to be built in AMU? And how can you stay in India if you do not accept the verdict of SC? The truth my friend is very clear for everyone to see. What Islam could not achieve since 622AD is still the main agenda of these people. They want to convert or kill every Hindu and make India an Islamic republic. Wherever Islam went, they converted or killed the entire population. India and its majority Hindu population remains a sore point for them.

why should any of this stop Modi from doing the right thing? Again- like Obama he could have done on ground what he thought was right while keeping everything legal.
 
why should any of this stop Modi from doing the right thing? Again- like Obama he could have done on ground what he thought was right while keeping everything legal.
Modi has gone as per the law of the land. when you create special laws for muslims and other minorities of India, article 14, 15 and 21 is not violated but the moment you apply it to Hindus and other religions specifically without excluding muslims, hell breaks lose. Please tell me how is the bill discriminatory? Give me one reason.
 
Modi has gone as per the law of the land. when you create special laws for muslims and other minorities of India, article 14, 15 and 21 is not violated but the moment you apply it to Hindus and other religions specifically without excluding muslims, hell breaks lose. Please tell me how is the bill discriminatory? Give me one reason.

no, he did no such thing. He just decided to do what he always does when he fails. Created another controversy. He is one of the biggest failurees India has had as a PM. Kiss all the superpower dreams goodbye man. Those days are over.
 
Modi never had a reason to create a discriminatory law. He could have passed a non discriminatory law and then made sure that only Hindus got acceptance.....but that would not have let him achieve the division he was planning and protests that would take attention away from his enormous failure as a PM. If India was growing at 12% a year you think he would have done this? He would have tomtommed that no end. Now because he is a failure he needs to rile up on all these issues.
Example the US ... Whites dont create discriminatory laws, but discriminate during implementation... Whites are not questioned or strip searched at airports.. whites dont get shot like dogs on the street like blacks do... also, enforcement agencies knock on white people's door before coming in... but, break the door and barge in I fit is a brown or a black..
I have no problem with the CAB. We live in a hostile islamic neighborhood and a point had to be made. As a standalone bill it is fine. But, pan india NRC on the lines of assam, is like burning down your house, to drive away the rats..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Manhunt
no, he did no such thing. He just decided to do what he always does when he fails. Created another controversy. He is one of the biggest failurees India has had as a PM. Kiss all the superpower dreams goodbye man. Those days are over.
Please remember opinions are like A$$holes, everyone has one including me and you.
 
Please remember opinions are like A$$holes, everyone has one including me and you.

But facts are not. He spent 5 years rigging the economy to favor his buddies. When that *censored*ed the economy and he realized that forcing media to lie about it isn't gonna work, he invents these things to take the attention away from real issues. at 9% growth, 8 years is enough to double an economy. Modi will definitely last beyond 8. Instead of doubling, economy is tumbling.
 
@S. A. T. A time for southern states to erect barricades on borders?There is precedent for this. In the 1960s when anti-civil rights movements took place in the south supported by the Ku Klux Klan and the lot, the northern states erected barricades to prevent them from entering their territory. We should start doing that.
chill down dude.