PM Says 3 Farm Laws To Be Cancelled

jetray

Senior member
Mar 15, 2018
1,595
1,002
India
BJP if succeeded anywhere since 1990s it's more or less the 39% which keeps voting for them. And BJP needs to stand for those 39% and be a Hindu, be a Nationalist and a Capitalist. All three equally important. Anything else done to impress the other 61% will never ever work for them. This is the sad reality.
Well if building & governing a nation was so easy ......taliban would have made afghanistan #1 in the world. If we follow a partisan approach how can we expect a optimum result? If govt has to succeed than it has to gain confidence of every cross section of the society. What applies to winning elections does not apply to successful governance.
 

jetray

Senior member
Mar 15, 2018
1,595
1,002
India
No socialist state has sadly lasted more than a generation. It seems our nation has very less time left then.

PS: China is anything but socialist.
This socialist , capitalist....dogma is good for studies practical world requires a mixture of both. Europe is more less socialist when it comes to labor policies, they are still a success.
Even the so called beacon of capitalist USA, still provides pension from govt coffers.
Its the only working car in this part of the world. We have already chosen the car and there is no going back.


Socialistic instincts cannot be fixed in a generation. And the RW is not helping be demonizing everyone who questions.
Indias mundane laws help none, more than socialist it is opportunistic politics.
 

Ankit Kumar

Senior member
Nov 30, 2017
2,561
2,344
Bangalore
Well if building & governing a nation was so easy ......taliban would have made afghanistan #1 in the world. If we follow a partisan approach how can we expect a optimum result? If govt has to succeed than it has to gain confidence of every cross section of the society. What applies to winning elections does not apply to successful governance.
Hindu-Nationalisim-Capitalism. No where in this does Taliban fit in.

And we are in such a state because we are trying to follow what you wrote.
 

Cole_phelps

Well-Known member
Jun 19, 2019
642
771
India
Today my hope died in BJP and Modi. Anarchism and rioting has won. Congratulations India, now decisions and policies will be made on roads. Sell both parliament and make them hotels.

You want something from govt, just block roads, hang mutilated body and drive tractors over police. No use of education and debate, thugs will always win in thuggery.

And this was the Modi they said was Hitler, Ravan and fascist, this weakling Modi!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Tatvamasi

jetray

Senior member
Mar 15, 2018
1,595
1,002
India
Hindu-Nationalisim-Capitalism. No where in this does Taliban fit in.

And we are in such a state because we are trying to follow what you wrote.
ways & means are different but mentality is same, my way or highway.

I certainly dont subscribe to the pro or against hindu party it is just opportunistic vote bank politics, if camels can vote our cows will turn into camels in no time. Nationalism & capitalism is for fools, these are words they use for one-upmanship. At the end of the day one group wants to be in power without delivering any thing and they keep fooling ppl with these idiosyncrasies.

We are in such a state bcos every ape in this country thinks they are more equal than others and they have some divine birth right to impose their way on others. End result is quite obvious that we will keep fighting among ourselves like we did for past 2000 years or so instead of looking forward to move ahead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maler

Saaho

Senior member
Dec 27, 2019
1,920
1,398
Earth
Today my hope died in BJP and Modi. Anarchism and rioting has won. Congratulations India, now decisions and policies will be made on roads. Sell both parliament and make them hotels.

You want something from govt, just block roads, hang mutilated body and drive tractors over police. No use of education and debate, thugs will always win in thuggery.

And this was the Modi they said was Hitler, Ravan and fascist, this weakling Modi!
You are not alone. Mark my word. BJP has started to disappoint its core supporters and cater to its "potential supporters". This strategy backfires a lot.

You cann't be right wing party and have a large tent politics like they are trying to do.

If you are right and have a sizeable core to support you, do not bow down to populist demands. Stand firm and implement right things with iron fist. Hellfire was right. Modi administration is Nehru 2.0. All we now need is an invasion from China and may be that will deliver the same blow to Modi as it did to Nehru. Alas, we do not have an Indra Gandhi in waiting to take the reins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cole_phelps

Saaho

Senior member
Dec 27, 2019
1,920
1,398
Earth
In the interst of Environment the Government should blast all the modern infrastructure away. Scarp every car.

Lets all go back 250 years and live in mud houses with thatch roof and use bullock carts.
If you are a big company, your loan gets waived off, if you are poor and unwilling to grow economically then again your loans will get waived off and you will get everything free.

But if you want to grow economically, build assets, pay taxes to the government so that you are ensured good infrastructure, security and other necessities.

Alarms, you are an idiot.
Someone has planted a deadly seed in the policy making and think tank of BJP. You do not flourish by borrowing your opponent's run book.

BJP is a nationalist party that is borrowing a liberal's playbook. It ends in a disaster.

The decision was based on politics. And even there it is stupid.

Downfall of BJP and Modi has started. It will not end well.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Tatvamasi

Cole_phelps

Well-Known member
Jun 19, 2019
642
771
India
Icing on the cake will be when Daikait and his accompanying leftist filth will start extracting more from Modi. They were dead and Modi dig them out and other irrelevant politicians from graves into limelight. What a master stroke, 3 D chess move.

BJP and RSS has gone woke. They will definitely face a blowback from TV studios to elections.
 

Saaho

Senior member
Dec 27, 2019
1,920
1,398
Earth
Icing on the cake will be when Daikait and his accompanying leftist filth will start extracting more from Modi. They were dead and Modi dig them out and other irrelevant politicians from graves into limelight. What a master stroke, 3 D chess move.

BJP and RSS has gone woke. They will definitely face a blowback from TV studios to elections.
They have not gone woke. They have gone greedy and desparate. It won't end well for them... sadly, neither for us as well.
 

Ankit Kumar

Senior member
Nov 30, 2017
2,561
2,344
Bangalore
These middlemen posing as farmers will now demand every single rupee of debt owned by anyone who can pose as a farmer to be wiped off.

And the public will support it.

Well every idiot who goes to the gas station and complains about high petrol prices but claps when farmer debts are wiped off, you and your family deserves it.
 

Cole_phelps

Well-Known member
Jun 19, 2019
642
771
India
This decision by Modi is a complete let down of the majority who voted for him. This decision will haunt BJP for years to come.

Turning back from this master stroke will not only require blood but also replacement of Modi himself. Modi was visionary as compared to current lot of politicians in India but has gone soft lately. Now that mobocracy has won and tasted blood, we can expect much bigger protests and riots. Only an iron leader within BJP can now revert this image of bent knees.

OTOH, Everyone knows BJP did this for votes, not due to Dikait and his band of clowns. Appeasement has never worked and never will, but will transform into violence sooner or later.
 

STEPHEN COHEN

Senior member
Dec 4, 2017
6,714
4,180
People are crying here totally Unnecessarily

Why can't we wait till UP elections are over

The state units of BJP in both UP and Punjab have given their inputs to the PM , for this decision

In Punjab , BJP wants to align with Amrinder Singh

So there has to be some way for Amrinder to announce a Partnership

Similarly Tikait would have taken away JAT votes in Western UP

UP will see a tough fight for every vote and every seat

The common farmer is now sufficiently aware that he must sell his produce directly to the consumer

Farmers if they want can form coooperatives to sell their produce directly to cut out middleman profits
 

STEPHEN COHEN

Senior member
Dec 4, 2017
6,714
4,180
Small Farmers need help with modern inputs to boost their Productivity like seeds , fertilizers , drip irrigation , pest control , post harvest management

These inputs can be provided by many Medium and Small scale industries

Perception Management is very crucial in politics

IF ADANI and AMBANI were to Capture this market , then naturally
It would imply that farm laws were
Brought by Modi for Modi's friends

In Punjab and Haryana , there are a number of Entrepreneurs who can tie up with small farmers

They too stand to benefit if Giant Companies stay away from Agriculture

Now it is upto the small farmer to protect his own interest

Modi has started Direct Payment in Farmers accounts in both Punjab and Haryana to cut out the middleman
 

STEPHEN COHEN

Senior member
Dec 4, 2017
6,714
4,180
In Punjab the BJP has a Hindu votebank

But due to This agitation , it was slipping towards Congress

But Now that Amrinder is out of Congress , There will be a 4 way split of votes

Between AAP , Akalis , BJP - Amrinder and Congress

It is also possible that Akalis and BJP
Come together again in a Post poll scenario

Farmers are also voters in India

UP Farmers were worried whether Large Companies will Pay at MSP or not after these new laws come into effect

 

SrNair

Active member
Mar 12, 2018
131
100
Kerala
To be honest .
Amit Shah is always right .The illiterates ,that too in significant number is actually a burden to this nation.
In 1947 India got independence and in 1948 communist China was established .
Now PRC is a 18 trillion economy and good life style and India is third world pathetic slum thanks to this kind of pathetic illiterates scums.

I mean why should we the middle class tolerate these kind of national waste .
Liability to themselves and liability to nation also.
PM Modi dont have anything to lose .
In fact he dont even care if it is not happen.

These morons was always ready to die as slaves .
Before it was for foreigners now for middlemens.
As per Suresh Gopi there is also national security issue involves here.

I would rather chose the Chinese system anyday better than these so called sub standard democracy
I was talking with a Panjabi girl, on a student visa. Who will get a PR on completion. She told me her entire school class has gone overseas, mostly Canada, US and Australia. I was amazed at that. For many years we have immigrated India's nurses and doctors. There are obviously other professions. We don't have unskilled immigration. It's a complete brain drain. It will affect Indian society.
What society .
These stupid society let them suffer who cares
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: AbRaj and Tatvamasi