MMRCA 2.0 - Updates and Discussions

What is your favorite for MMRCA 2.0 ?

  • F-35 Blk 4

    Votes: 44 16.4%
  • Rafale F4

    Votes: 205 76.5%
  • Eurofighter Typhoon T3

    Votes: 5 1.9%
  • Gripen E/F

    Votes: 5 1.9%
  • F-16 B70

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • F-18 SH

    Votes: 10 3.7%
  • F-15EX

    Votes: 11 4.1%
  • Mig-35

    Votes: 2 0.7%

  • Total voters
    268
  • Poll closed .
K. R. Naidu currently serves as India's Union Minister of Civil Aviation. Jyotiraditya has already left. Portfolio changed a while ago.

Right. I forgot.

The Su-30 MKI can be utilised in our neighbourhood. Re-order past the 12 already in place and ask HAL to ramp upgrades as well. Buy x odd Sqdrns in fly-away condition. I said this in another thread a while back.

The French will not give concessions. They are not in a good place economically. For now, the babus can just get the best rate possible and close the deal for a flyaway lot.

This is what we get for delaying MMRCA/MRFA interminably and not keeping a L2 option open. The French know we have money locked in on the Rafale and will be in no mood to oblige us on ToT, ICD, etc.

We are down to <30 sqns now and DefSec Rajesh Singh still seemed unsure about our future force structure. 114 Rafale are pretty much unavoidable.

Any cuts to Mk2 would directly impact AMCA and embolden the Frenchies even more, imo
 
This is what we get for delaying MMRCA/MRFA interminably and not keeping a L2 option open. The French know we have money locked in on the Rafale and will be in no mood to oblige us on ToT, ICD, etc.

We are down to <30 sqns now and DefSec Rajesh Singh still seemed unsure about our future force structure. 114 Rafale are pretty much unavoidable.

Any cuts to Mk2 would directly impact AMCA and embolden the Frenchies even more, imo
Two things:

I do not like singular reporting that is source based and will not give away details that are necessary to mull things over. Snehashish has left ThePrint and I no longer have a reason to pay attention to their defence reporting. I do not place a lot of weight on what they have to say in other areas of NatSec.

Coming to the MMRCA. You've pretty much got the gist of it. The French know that we do not have options when it comes to 4.5 gen FAs and will try to play hardball. I would to if I was in their position. The money needs to come from somewhere.

Secondly, it was a big mistake not fund an essential project like a Jet Engine. There is a price tag associated with mistakes of such proportions. There are plenty of reasons that the project has not achieved success. However, when looked at from a Project Management perspective, I would say a large part also has to do with the infrastructure investment and the funding provided by the MoD. If they would have funded it properly, I would have looked at the SCN lines differently and come to a different conclusion altogether. Weights would have shifted accordingly and I would be discussion certain other aspects that might have had a disproportionate amount of impact on the project as a whole.

I now understand why RR is angling for a shot and continues to engage the MoD as well as MEA. They sense an opportunity and are willing to take a chance. They have nothing to loose and a whole lot to gain. This is of course for the AMCA Engine. They want a long term relationship and a client that is willing to play ball with them.

For now, in order to get the FA sqdrns up, MoD will have to bite the bullet. 114 or Flyaway either will be fine. The two front thing will not see its scenario change much even if the entire lot goes through. However, IAF will do itself a dis-service if it compromises on the aspects that it is paying for and expects to have.

I have spoken in favour of the Rafale and I believe it is a good 4.5 gen FA. However, if the French will not provide 30-40 percent localisation and do not agree to ISE that IAF is looking wants then it is better to cut the lot size. Order a fly-away batch and take care of the western sector.

AIP and High-capacity Engines for Land based systems were invested in as they were considered essential. Both of these are either in trial or will undergo trials.

It is most unfortunate that MoD could not see the Jet Engine program through in a timely manner. I think that the Su-30 MKI fleet can be expanded and the FA can continue to play its role in the next decade as well. The Rafale is not a silver bullet that can be a solution to certain issues that the IAF is currently facing.

The French can be negotiated with and made to understand certain things. If they cannot, reduce the lot size, shake their hands and....pleasure doing business with you.

Sorry about the long-winded reply.