MMRCA 2.0 - Updates and Discussions

What is your favorite for MMRCA 2.0 ?

  • F-35 Blk 4

    Votes: 44 16.4%
  • Rafale F4

    Votes: 205 76.5%
  • Eurofighter Typhoon T3

    Votes: 5 1.9%
  • Gripen E/F

    Votes: 5 1.9%
  • F-16 B70

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • F-18 SH

    Votes: 10 3.7%
  • F-15EX

    Votes: 11 4.1%
  • Mig-35

    Votes: 2 0.7%

  • Total voters
    268
  • Poll closed .
What is the delay in this deal

Second what is the new split between F5 and F4 versions

I hope it's 50% order for Rafale F5
 
Hical Technologies Signs MoU with Safran Aerosystems to Explore the creation of a Joint Venture for manufacturing of Complex Rafale Systems in India
Bengaluru (Karnataka) [India], October 7: Hical Technologies, a Bengaluru-based precision electromechanical manufacturer serving global aerospace and defence platforms, today announced the signing of a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with Safran Aerosystems to explore the creation of a joint venture for the manufacture of complex systems for the Dassault Rafale program in India.
The proposed joint venture would focus on the production of sophisticated equipment, including complex fluid and fuel systems and related assemblies, for Rafale aircraft delivered under the Make in India initiative. The MoU reflects the growing role of Indian industry in global aerospace and defence supply chains and underscores Safran Aerosystems’ commitment to deepen its collaboration with high-quality private-sector partners in India.

“This proposed partnership reflects Safran Aerosystems’ continued commitment to India and to the development of its private-sector aerospace ecosystem,” said Joel Berkoukchi, CEO, Fluid & Fuel Systems Division, Safran Aerosystems . “As programmes such as Rafale demand depth, quality and scale in the supply chain, Hical’s expanding capacity – including its new facility in Devanahalli – will be important in supporting the advanced manufacturing requirements for complex fuel and fluid systems and other critical equipment in India.”

The MoU builds on Hical’s growing involvement in the Rafale ecosystem. Hical has already been selected to work directly with Dassault Aviation on control systems for the Rafale programme. The proposed joint venture would create an opportunity for Hical to expand further into complex systems manufacturing, supporting India’s movement up the aerospace value chain under the Make in India initiative.

The announcement coincides with a major expansion of Hical’s aerospace manufacturing capabilities. The company recently inaugurated its new aerospace manufacturing facility in Devanahalli, near Bengaluru.

This expansion forms part of Hical’s broader strategy to build the scale, capability and manufacturing depth required to support increasingly sophisticated aerospace and defence programmes delivered from India to global customers.

“This MoU marks an important milestone for Hical as we move into more complex systems manufacturing for demanding aerospace platforms such as Rafale. By combining Safran Aerosystems’ technology leadership with Hical’s growing manufacturing footprint in India, we aim to support the Make in India vision and demonstrate that critical aerospace systems can be designed, industrialised and produced competitively in India for the world.” – Yashas Jaiveer, Managing Director, Hical Technologies
 

It is at the RFP submission stage. They've given their bids, and they are being evaluated. After that, we'll start taking it up. We should be able to reach some conclusion in that procurement cycle before the end of this year.
Even with the IAF 36 first contract, israeli SPICE guided bombs had to be integrated (may be replaced by Hammer ?), and it was said that ASTRA also had to be integrated.
 
Astra and SAAW were in Navy Deal.

Astra was not ready in 2016.
From 2022
Bharat Dynamics Limited (BDL) and Dassault Aviation Pvt. Ltd. entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) on Friday for Integration of BDL Weapon Systems like Astra & Smart Anti-Airfield Weapon on Rafale aircraft for Indian Armed Forces and future export market.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Photon Vish
Cant be asking for core technologies and keep pushing for them, France has built a fully integrated ecosystems around that thing and their navy and air force literally almost fully depends upon that thing for operations in combat aviation, one wouldn't just give up the core technologies of a 4+ gen multirole jet that they spent last 2 decades building a full ecosystems and their forces nearly depend on fully just cause a outside party gives a sizable order as a customer.
 
Unfortunately, there are many within the defence community as well as MoD who cannot seem to wrap their head around the idea presented above. There will be limits to what a JV can and cannot have. Many things can be discussed and implemented. However, there will always be certain aspects which the OEM will not be willing to share and will keep them off the table.

On a separate note, certain MoD tendencies as well as procurement tendencies of the forces themselves can be seen from Land systems that the IA has been placing orders for as well. DRDO and BF had launched truck based howitzers. However, there has been little news about their trials. It is quite hard to even discern if there is interest within the IA in acquiring them. BF has in the meantime exported the system and that speaks adequately about its actual capability.

If MoD wishes to truly enhance its own domestic capabilities that can be of use in a pinch, it will have to show some spine and place orders that might displease its regular foreign OEM partners. Core tech more often than not needs to be done in-house. This applies for all domains.

The same goes for R&D push as well. The GoI should understand that it will have to show interest and invest considerably in various domains either through PPP or other means to get things done. R&D track record of the private sector can show further improvement. The Govt. needs to show some "concern" and things will start to gradually improve. How the concern needs to be shown is known well to the babus and netas.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: YoungWolf
I mean isn't it expected?
No one will part core/critical technologies they spent decades to develop and mature, no matter how many $$$$ you are willing to funnel in their bank accounts.
that too, in case of the rafale, i would say that is on par as a national strategic asset for French as their nuclear weapons are due to the amount of roles ( including being the platform that will perform nuclear strikes from air), and now since the FCAS collapse, it is clear for them that they are gonna depend on the platform for like at least 15 years probably, the incentive of safeguarding it has only shot up for them, and no one can be mad about it as long as one thinks in even remote rationality. honestly if they did actually agreed for core tech transfer, i would have thought "they were really kind of fitting the slander and stereotypes they usually get on the internet".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aniruddha
Cant be asking for core technologies and keep pushing for them, France has built a fully integrated ecosystems around that thing and their navy and air force literally almost fully depends upon that thing for operations in combat aviation, one wouldn't just give up the core technologies of a 4+ gen multirole jet that they spent last 2 decades building a full ecosystems and their forces nearly depend on fully just cause a outside party gives a sizable order as a customer.
Its not just a sizable order. It is probably the biggest order an airforce will give to a foreign jet with a price tag of 36 billion euros. French have no problem giving technology to UAE and Ukraine. Our bureaucrats don't know how negotiate or rather they don't want to. Import lobby has become so strong that words from hukum2082 tweet which I have posted here several times is now coming out from mouth of Defence Secretary. It seems we are not even getting ICD access. These guys are not even willing to part with 40 year technology of Mirage 2000 and M88. And yet are claiming they will give full ToT of AMCA engine.

From the article:
​
Safran’s caution on the M88 contrasts with its offer for another program: the engine of future versions of the AMCA, the fighter aircraft designed by India. Olivier Andriès mentioned, in November 2025 in The Economic Times, a “complete transfer of technologies”, a joint development with the DRDO, the Indian defense research agency, and Indian intellectual property rights on critical elements.​


IAF has gone in damage control mode after this article, and the above tweet was quoted by Congress Party's Pawan Khera.

https://x.com/Pawankhera/status/2122600292407726499



The Indian Air Force (IAF) will integrate the homegrown beyond-visual-range air-to-air Astra missile on its French-origin Rafale fighter jets, as the freedom to fit and use weapons of its choice without needing any foreign approval is one of its two non-negotiables for the 114 additional jets being acquired, a source in the know told ThePrint Wednesday.​
 
  • Like
Reactions: Speedster1
Its not just a sizable order. It is probably the biggest order an airforce will give to a foreign jet with a price tag of 36 billion euros. French have no problem giving technology to UAE and Ukraine. Our bureaucrats don't know how negotiate or rather they don't want to. Import lobby has become so strong that words from hukum2082 tweet which I have posted here several times is now coming out from mouth of Defence Secretary. It seems we are not even getting ICD access. These guys are not even willing to part with 40 year technology of Mirage 2000 and M88. And yet are claiming they will give full ToT of AMCA engine.

From the article:
​



IAF has gone in damage control mode after this article, and the above tweet was quoted by Congress Party's Pawan Khera.

https://x.com/Pawankhera/status/2122600292407726499



The Indian Air Force (IAF) will integrate the homegrown beyond-visual-range air-to-air Astra missile on its French-origin Rafale fighter jets, as the freedom to fit and use weapons of its choice without needing any foreign approval is one of its two non-negotiables for the 114 additional jets being acquired, a source in the know told ThePrint Wednesday.​

We just don't know/care about leveraging our massive market size to extract ToT out of foreign oem like China does.

Its the same situation w/commercial airliner where we have hundreds of Airbus A320/21s on order but no movement on a local FAL. We are content with some sub assembly work.

The Civil aviation minister Jyotiraditya Scindia seems to be much more knowledgeable/persuasive than Rajnath but so far he's been unable to bring Airbus to heel.
 
The Su-30 MKI can be utilised in our neighbourhood. Re-order past the 12 already in place and ask HAL to ramp upgrades as well. Buy x odd Sqdrns in fly-away condition. I said this in another thread a while back.

The French will not give concessions. They are not in a good place economically. For now, the babus can just get the best rate possible and close the deal for a flyaway lot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aniruddha