Why have ‘liberals’ reduced themselves to being anti-nationals?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually guys like him are so predictable its boring. Pulling out senseless statements like these when you are out of logic or statements is just lame.
While we are at it, let me say that patriotism is the pinnacle of evolution of society. Scoundrels have no refuge anywhere anyway.
The pinnacle of evolution of any society is decadence. As a society and civilization we've already been there . Just before our 1000 year journey of slavery began.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Aravind
That is true. Being anti BJP does not mean anti India, but politics in our country has turned a corner where political parties are not differentiated on nuances but rather by considerably different tracks they have chosen to tread.
On one hand you have self flagellating leftist cabal and on other side you have the likes of Shiv Sena. The only correct way is the middle way, the centre of right way.
Who else is there but BJP right now. One can oppose its policies but opposing BJP means supporting another party. Which party do you support and why?
That is a genuine conundrum. Congress has 0 credibility. BJP invariably emboldens the fringe and lunatic right. In Maharashtra, Fadnavis has done a good job - no scandals, genuine attempt at bringing e-governance to the fore and an impetus to infrastructure - I will vote for BJP at the State level. Even in Modi's Government - I certainly prefer that my coal and power minister is Goyal rather than Shibu Soren - pretty much the same goes for all ministries. But I think morons like Satyapal Singh and thugs like Amit Shah should be shown the door - the former is a fool, so one can forgive. But I think Amit Shah is the guy who will eventually sink Modi. If I vote for BJP in the Lok Sabha polls - it will only be because of lack of options.
 
That is a genuine conundrum. Congress has 0 credibility. BJP invariably emboldens the fringe and lunatic right. In Maharashtra, Fadnavis has done a good job - no scandals, genuine attempt at bringing e-governance to the fore and an impetus to infrastructure - I will vote for BJP at the State level. Even in Modi's Government - I certainly prefer that my coal and power minister is Goyal rather than Shibu Soren - pretty much the same goes for all ministries. But I think morons like Satyapal Singh and thugs like Amit Shah should be shown the door - the former is a fool, so one can forgive. But I think Amit Shah is the guy who will eventually sink Modi. If I vote for BJP in the Lok Sabha polls - it will only be because of lack of options.
Amit Shah will go to jail for murdering judge Loya and he will take Modi along with him. and RSS will be banned for 10 years.

@bonobashi @Tatvamasi

There is something terribly wrong with this country. Cruelty and injustice, intolerance and oppression. And where once we had the freedom to object, to think and speak as we saw fit, we now have censors and systems of surveillance coercing our conformity and soliciting our submission.

How did this happen? Who’s to blame? Well certainly there are those more responsible than others, and they will be held accountable, but again truth be told, if we’re looking for the guilty, we need only look into a mirror. I know why we did it. we were afraid. Who wouldn’t be? Love Jihad propaganda, Terrorism, ISIS, Sonia Gandhi being Italian, Rahul Gandhi, Corruption, Black money etc. There were a myriad of problems which conspired to corrupt our reason and rob us of our common sense. Fear got the best of us, and in our panic we turned to this Right Wing Modi government. They promised us order, they promised us peace, and all they demanded in return was our silent, obedient consent.

We should end this silence, to remind this country of what it has forgotten. My hope is to remind this nation that fairness, justice, and freedom are more than words, they are perspectives. So if you’ve seen nothing, if the crimes of this Modi government remain unknown to you then I would suggest you ignore me.

But if you see what I see, if you feel as I feel, and if you would seek as I seek, then I ask you to stand up against Cruelty and injustice, intolerance and oppression, and together we should give them a reply in 2019 elections that shall never, ever be forgot. People should not be afraid of their governments. Governments should be afraid of their people. Strength through unity, unity through faith!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Invidious
Amit Shah will go to jail for murdering judge Loya and he will take Modi along with him. and RSS will be banned for 10 years.

@bonobashi @Tatvamasi

There is something terribly wrong with this country. Cruelty and injustice, intolerance and oppression. And where once we had the freedom to object, to think and speak as we saw fit, we now have censors and systems of surveillance coercing our conformity and soliciting our submission.

How did this happen? Who’s to blame? Well certainly there are those more responsible than others, and they will be held accountable, but again truth be told, if we’re looking for the guilty, we need only look into a mirror. I know why we did it. we were afraid. Who wouldn’t be? Love Jihad propaganda, Terrorism, ISIS, Sonia Gandhi being Italian, Rahul Gandhi, Corruption, Black money etc. There were a myriad of problems which conspired to corrupt our reason and rob us of our common sense. Fear got the best of us, and in our panic we turned to this Right Wing Modi government. They promised us order, they promised us peace, and all they demanded in return was our silent, obedient consent.

We should end this silence, to remind this country of what it has forgotten. My hope is to remind this nation that fairness, justice, and freedom are more than words, they are perspectives. So if you’ve seen nothing, if the crimes of this Modi government remain unknown to you then I would suggest you ignore me.

But if you see what I see, if you feel as I feel, and if you would seek as I seek, then I ask you to stand up against Cruelty and injustice, intolerance and oppression, and together we should give them a reply in 2019 elections that shall never, ever be forgot. People should not be afraid of their governments. Governments should be afraid of their people. Strength through unity, unity through faith!

I completely concur. Unfortunately, the so-called liberal left has sacrificed common sense and true liberal values on the altar of political correctness. The same left liberals who were once against Jews being forced to wear Star of David armbands in Nazi Germany - once argued with me that the Taliban forcing minorities to wear similar bands was "part of Afghan culture". That is utter rubbish. If a sect or religion promotes any ideal which is opposed to liberal ideals it should be vehemently opposed, not accommodated. That's where the left has failed and given rise to the right. Today the lines between Trump supporters and Karni Sena is negligible.
 
I completely concur. Unfortunately, the so-called liberal left has sacrificed common sense and true liberal values on the altar of political correctness. The same left liberals who were once against Jews being forced to wear Star of David armbands in Nazi Germany - once argued with me that the Taliban forcing minorities to wear similar bands was "part of Afghan culture". That is utter rubbish. If a sect or religion promotes any ideal which is opposed to liberal ideals it should be vehemently opposed, not accommodated. That's where the left has failed and given rise to the right. Today the lines between Trump supporters and Karni Sena is negligible.


In case you haven't noticed , his views are more left wing .But don't be guided by my views. Keep him engaged . You've asked for it , you've had it .
 
Amit Shah will go to jail for murdering judge Loya and he will take Modi along with him. and RSS will be banned for 10 years.

LOL, love the conspiracy theories and fantasies.

I guess it beats looking at the mirror and actually trying to sort out the reality of whats looking back at you.

Keep doing it, it helps the right win more. It feels great to look at political map of India now and what the clear established trend is....all due to EVM hacking supposedly (and anything else you concoct and bray about).

Real India should not rest till congress is completely removed from the political space just like the British that left it there.

Best part is till the end you will cry foul and cannot accept the reality it was the Indian people losing patience with you scumbags. That dissonance will be very enjoyable to me, and you all fully deserve it for what you lot did to my country.
 
Amit Shah will go to jail for murdering judge Loya and he will take Modi along with him. and RSS will be banned for 10 years.

@bonobashi @Tatvamasi

There is something terribly wrong with this country. Cruelty and injustice, intolerance and oppression. And where once we had the freedom to object, to think and speak as we saw fit, we now have censors and systems of surveillance coercing our conformity and soliciting our submission.

How did this happen? Who’s to blame? Well certainly there are those more responsible than others, and they will be held accountable, but again truth be told, if we’re looking for the guilty, we need only look into a mirror. I know why we did it. we were afraid. Who wouldn’t be? Love Jihad propaganda, Terrorism, ISIS, Sonia Gandhi being Italian, Rahul Gandhi, Corruption, Black money etc. There were a myriad of problems which conspired to corrupt our reason and rob us of our common sense. Fear got the best of us, and in our panic we turned to this Right Wing Modi government. They promised us order, they promised us peace, and all they demanded in return was our silent, obedient consent.

We should end this silence, to remind this country of what it has forgotten. My hope is to remind this nation that fairness, justice, and freedom are more than words, they are perspectives. So if you’ve seen nothing, if the crimes of this Modi government remain unknown to you then I would suggest you ignore me.

But if you see what I see, if you feel as I feel, and if you would seek as I seek, then I ask you to stand up against Cruelty and injustice, intolerance and oppression, and together we should give them a reply in 2019 elections that shall never, ever be forgot. People should not be afraid of their governments. Governments should be afraid of their people. Strength through unity, unity through faith!
Why are you causing pollution by speaking contentless things? Other than that you hate Modi and want Muslims and other vile people to go unpunished for their crimes you are conveying nothing else. Intolerance towards evil is the only right thing. No one ever said tolerating everything is correct.

I completely concur. Unfortunately, the so-called liberal left has sacrificed common sense and true liberal values on the altar of political correctness. The same left liberals who were once against Jews being forced to wear Star of David armbands in Nazi Germany - once argued with me that the Taliban forcing minorities to wear similar bands was "part of Afghan culture". That is utter rubbish. If a sect or religion promotes any ideal which is opposed to liberal ideals it should be vehemently opposed, not accommodated. That's where the left has failed and given rise to the right. Today the lines between Trump supporters and Karni Sena is negligible.

What is liberal ideals? Suicide by being a coward or being mentally unsound completely oblivious of reality? Why not be natural? Of course, violence is a part and parcel of life and right amount of violence will be needed everytime to maintain truth and fight off evil forces that pop up.

Don't use the word minority, use the correct classification. The minority in Afghanistan don't exactly behave like the minority in India. How is minority even a group in the first place? Use proper grouping, not arbitrary. Also, minority in terms of what? If you are even considering religion here, then you are proving that religion matters the most and hence making your own point meaningless.

Why would you call Amit Shah as a thug? Because you have mental problems? Isn't there a difference between a warrior and a thug? Why shouldn't I call you as protitute and a parasite who is wasting my precious resource of food, water and land while giving nothing in return?
 
Commies are NOT liberal under any definition of the word. They believe in use of bloodshed to gain power and once in power suspend all civilian liberties and run oppressive genicidal regimes.

They also do not believe in the concept of a modern nation state, hence expecting them to be patriotic or nationalistic is futile.

Essentially commie and even islamists have usurped the term liberal. This should be fought in public perception first. Saying liberals are bad is self defeating as the idea of india is essentially liberal and inclusive.
Not for long, will it remain. To get gold you have to reheat and reheat a lot of times to concentrate the gold to get rid of its impurities. That is the change i see now.
The chaff is blown away from the wheat.
These are not Liberal and Inclusive.
Once the gold is established, it can go back to its liberalism , inclusiveness etc. whatever you like.
Just like you mix 24k carat gold with other metals to form different things (That is Liberalism and Inclusiveness simply explained)
 
And where once we had the freedom to object, to think and speak as we saw fit, we now have censors and systems of surveillance coercing our conformity and soliciting our submission.
who banned tasleema nasreens book?
who banned salman rushdies book?
why werent cartoons of the mohammed printed from the danish news papers in India?

while the secularists supported MF HUssain painted saraswati nude why wasnt the same support given to salman rushdie or tasleema nasreen?
 
My hope is to remind this nation that fairness, justice, and freedom are more than words, they are perspectives. So if you’ve seen nothing, if the crimes of this Modi government remain unknown to you then I would suggest you ignore me.

tell me - how many communal riots happened during the congress regime?
the anti sikh riots
the anti brahmin ideology of the south
the anti hindi riots of the south
oh
and the fariness and justice of that was offered to shah bano?
or the anderson guy (bhopal gas tragedy) was let away by Rahul Gandhi?
or the way PV Narsimha rao (one of the architects of our economic revolution) was "fairly" treated by congress (his name being erased from every congress scheme - cos his last name is not Gandhi)
 
Amit Shah will go to jail for murdering judge Loya and he will take Modi along with him. and RSS will be banned for 10 years.

@bonobashi @Tatvamasi

There is something terribly wrong with this country. Cruelty and injustice, intolerance and oppression. And where once we had the freedom to object, to think and speak as we saw fit, we now have censors and systems of surveillance coercing our conformity and soliciting our submission.

How did this happen? Who’s to blame? Well certainly there are those more responsible than others, and they will be held accountable, but again truth be told, if we’re looking for the guilty, we need only look into a mirror. I know why we did it. we were afraid. Who wouldn’t be? Love Jihad propaganda, Terrorism, ISIS, Sonia Gandhi being Italian, Rahul Gandhi, Corruption, Black money etc. There were a myriad of problems which conspired to corrupt our reason and rob us of our common sense. Fear got the best of us, and in our panic we turned to this Right Wing Modi government. They promised us order, they promised us peace, and all they demanded in return was our silent, obedient consent.

We should end this silence, to remind this country of what it has forgotten. My hope is to remind this nation that fairness, justice, and freedom are more than words, they are perspectives. So if you’ve seen nothing, if the crimes of this Modi government remain unknown to you then I would suggest you ignore me.

But if you see what I see, if you feel as I feel, and if you would seek as I seek, then I ask you to stand up against Cruelty and injustice, intolerance and oppression, and together we should give them a reply in 2019 elections that shall never, ever be forgot. People should not be afraid of their governments. Governments should be afraid of their people. Strength through unity, unity through faith!
You got proof for Amit shah?
Loyas case his son came out to say it on tv 'Please dont politicize my fathers death'.

what is with this farcical case of Ishrat jahan terrorist encounter that Amit shah was accused of? Even Bihar disowned that beti.
You just keep hoping that Modi will go down. When 'Congis' are out of cash to contest elections. :cry:

Yeah Yeah , all your projects fail, Modi still leads the polls as favourite.
Keep jerking off till 2024 when Yogi Adityanath takes over :D
 
Why are you causing pollution by speaking contentless things? Other than that you hate Modi and want Muslims and other vile people to go unpunished for their crimes you are conveying nothing else. Intolerance towards evil is the only right thing. No one ever said tolerating everything is correct.



What is liberal ideals? Suicide by being a coward or being mentally unsound completely oblivious of reality? Why not be natural? Of course, violence is a part and parcel of life and right amount of violence will be needed everytime to maintain truth and fight off evil forces that pop up.

Don't use the word minority, use the correct classification. The minority in Afghanistan don't exactly behave like the minority in India. How is minority even a group in the first place? Use proper grouping, not arbitrary. Also, minority in terms of what? If you are even considering religion here, then you are proving that religion matters the most and hence making your own point meaningless.

Why would you call Amit Shah as a thug? Because you have mental problems? Isn't there a difference between a warrior and a thug? Why shouldn't I call you as protitute and a parasite who is wasting my precious resource of food, water and land while giving nothing in return?

LOL - Prostitute? Parasite? Mental problems? Your resources? Hahahaha. Another keyboard warrior. You are nothing more than a wannabe Indian - probably an illegal immigrant from Bangladesh trying hard to blend in. LOL - where you got your fake Aadhar from?
 
Yes - you are right. Unfortunately, a significant number of people especially on social media have stopped distinguishing their Government from their nation. Everyone has the right to criticize any institution in a nation - be it the Government, the Armed Forces or the Judiciary. There is a reason why the Armed Forces have Military Police as well as Court Martial as well as Military Law .
That's fair enough but I see a big difference between criticizing armed forces for their shortcomings (which we all do) and the open derision displayed by the liberal loony in OP.
 
who banned tasleema nasreens book?
who banned salman rushdies book?
why werent cartoons of the mohammed printed from the danish news papers in India?

while the secularists supported MF HUssain painted saraswati nude why wasnt the same support given to salman rushdie or tasleema nasreen?

Which M F Hussain? The one who shelved his movie when some muslims objected to one of the songs? Bro these guys are hypocrites. They do not believe in liberalism at all.

First challenge is to call them correctly for what they are, paid propagandists, communists, islamists, anti hindu activists etc etc.
 
Why are you causing pollution by speaking contentless things? Other than that you hate Modi and want Muslims and other vile people to go unpunished for their crimes you are conveying nothing else. Intolerance towards evil is the only right thing. No one ever said tolerating everything is correct.



What is liberal ideals? Suicide by being a coward or being mentally unsound completely oblivious of reality? Why not be natural? Of course, violence is a part and parcel of life and right amount of violence will be needed everytime to maintain truth and fight off evil forces that pop up.

Don't use the word minority, use the correct classification. The minority in Afghanistan don't exactly behave like the minority in India. How is minority even a group in the first place? Use proper grouping, not arbitrary. Also, minority in terms of what? If you are even considering religion here, then you are proving that religion matters the most and hence making your own point meaningless.

Why would you call Amit Shah as a thug? Because you have mental problems? Isn't there a difference between a warrior and a thug? Why shouldn't I call you as protitute and a parasite who is wasting my precious resource of food, water and land while giving nothing in return?
1. I asked to ignore the post if you don't agree with it.

2. I don't hate Modi - he is just too boring and stupid, who can't even face a interview :sleep:... he is just a gloried mob boss.

3. How come Indian muslims are vile people who should be punished, what kind of insane logic is this. 90% of the Muslims in this country are ex-Hindus, some where impressed by Sufis, some converted under coercion, some for better status in Muslim rule and some wanted to escape caste system. Just because invaders during medieval period happened to be Muslim, I should be intolerant towards Muslims.
Basically, you are suggesting to drive a car looking at the rear view mirror.

I have seen many Hindus converting to Islam but I have rarely seen any reverse conversion. Maybe they are very happy with the spiritual path they have chosen. If they are happy with their choice, my best wishes to them.
 
1. I asked to ignore the post if you don't agree with it.

2. I don't hate Modi - he is just too boring and stupid, who can't even face a interview :sleep:... he is just a gloried mob boss.

3. How come Indian muslims are vile people who should be punished, what kind of insane logic is this. 90% of the Muslims in this country are ex-Hindus, some where impressed by Sufis, some converted under coercion, some for better status in Muslim rule and some wanted to escape caste system. Just because invaders during medieval period happened to be Muslim, I should be intolerant towards Muslims.
Basically, you are suggesting to drive a car looking at the rear view mirror.

I have seen many Hindus converting to Islam but I have rarely seen any reverse conversion. Maybe they are very happy with the spiritual path they have chosen. If they are happy with their choice, my best wishes to them.

There was only 1 muslim initially - Muhammad. Obviously every muslim is a convert. Islam was not spread because people found spiritual guidance but because of cowardice and greed. Invaders in medieval times were of all sects. Shakas, hunas etc also invaded. But Muslims stand out of it and had a long term agenda rather than just control over resources.

Every convert is one who betrayed their ancestors and truth for cowardice and greed. Obviously traitors must not be tolerated. If you are Ok with muslims killing, why are you not Ok with hindus doing same? Time is unending. There is no point discriminating actions out if time difference. In the span of billions of years of this universe, a thousand year hardly has any significance. So, action done a thousand years back can't be considered differently than actions done today.

Modi is boring is a retarded statement as he was never there for entertainment
 
  • Like
Reactions: NRJ and Aravind
There was only 1 muslim initially - Muhammad. Obviously every muslim is a convert. Islam was not spread because people found spiritual guidance but because of cowardice and greed. Invaders in medieval times were of all sects. Shakas, hunas etc also invaded. But Muslims stand out of it and had a long term agenda rather than just control over resources.

Every convert is one who betrayed their ancestors and truth for cowardice and greed. Obviously traitors must not be tolerated. If you are Ok with muslims killing, why are you not Ok with hindus doing same? Time is unending. There is no point discriminating actions out if time difference. In the span of billions of years of this universe, a thousand year hardly has any significance. So, action done a thousand years back can't be considered differently than actions done today.

Modi is boring is a retarded statement as he was never there for entertainment

Finalyyyyy the meeting of two great intellects of our generation on this forum . What a treat and feast for our mental faculties !! You two provide excellent food for thought and thorough nourishment for the soul .

Just a humble suggestion - aap dono saandhe ke Tel Ka vyapaar kyon Nahin karte , saajhedaari mein ?

@Kshithij Sharma ; @Infowarrior
 
  • Like
Reactions: Notsuperstitious
who banned tasleema nasreens book?
who banned salman rushdies book?
why werent cartoons of the mohammed printed from the danish news papers in India?

while the secularists supported MF HUssain painted saraswati nude why wasnt the same support given to salman rushdie or tasleema nasreen?
I'm against all kinds of unnecessary censorship, after 4 years of Modi government. I'm sure that muslim fundamentals have learned their lessons, they have been shown the mirror, it is upto them now, adapt or perish. Hint: sacrifice the Babri masjid issue like they, sacrifice animals during bakri id, :unsure:.

tell me - how many communal riots happened during the congress regime?
the anti sikh riots
the anti brahmin ideology of the south
the anti hindi riots of the south
oh
and the fariness and justice of that was offered to shah bano?
or the anderson guy (bhopal gas tragedy) was let away by Rahul Gandhi?
or the way PV Narsimha rao (one of the architects of our economic revolution) was "fairly" treated by congress (his name being erased from every congress scheme - cos his last name is not Gandhi)
Two wrongs don't make a right :p

Finalyyyyy the meeting of two great intellects of our generation on this forum . What a treat and feast for our mental faculties !! You two provide excellent food for thought and thorough nourishment for the soul .



Just a humble suggestion - aap dono saandhe ke Tel Ka vyapaar kyon Nahin karte , saajhedaari mein ?



@Kshithij Sharma ; @Infowarrior

Logic >>> articulation
 
Last edited:
This is one of the most absurd things spoken. When the arguments are well reasoned, why should an ill reasoned argument be given any space? Opinions are mere noise pollution. I am not here to discuss about your feelings. Only truth will be discussed. if your words are nonsensical and reflects your whims then we are not the people whom you must be talking to.

If there are evil people, they will be abused. However, the reason for abusing will be given and questions regarding it will be clarified. Not abusing evil people is unacceptable

Good Morning Kshithij,

This tread was created because of what happened the other day between good selves and me AND Ashwins response.
You feel aggrieved that Ashwin attempted to stay neutral. Because you didnt get the desired outcome - you think you can highlight it and make the assumption that Liberals are anti - nationals. Clever - not so. Its so transparent that its hilarious.
I hold an opinion and speak for just myself - and no one else. I dont have allegiance to Islam - even though im a Muslim - i try to be objective and call a spade a spade. Read my posts to verify this.

I stand by what i state and wish to discuss all topics with people with various views and opinions. I dont and wont allow preferential treatment and if i step out of line - expect to be banned. However i can see when someone is irritated by my presence. Allowing me a platform to debate - doesnt make the Admin Liberal - it just creates a platform for debate.

Peace.
 
Patriotism is the last refuge of scoundrels:whistle:


They always hide behind patriotism and religion.

I dont have an issue with patriotism - being passionate about ones nation is no crime. When it becomes blind - then its dangerous.
I dont have an issue with ANY religion. My partner is a staunch strict Hindu. I respect and love him and vice versa. We never disrespect each other beliefs.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Shashank
Status
Not open for further replies.