Lok Sabha passes Citizenship Bill amidst Opposition outcry

How The National Anthem United the CAA Protesters and the Delhi Police, For a Moment

A video from the location shows protesters against CAA come face-to-face with Delhi Police, who had direct orders to detain anyone. In the video, the protesters can be heard singing the national anthem.



On Thursday, December 19, India saw country-wide protests opposing the Citizenship (Amendment) Act.

Protests around the country took many forms, even as police permissions were cancelled, and Section 144 which prevents unlawful assembly were imposed in several parts of the country.

In Delhi, thousands of students, activists and opposition leaders hit the streets defying heavy security clampdown and prohibitory orders even as authorities suspended mobile internet services and restricted traffic movement to quell the swirling agitation.

Opposition leaders D Raja, Sitaram Yechury, Nilotpal Basu, Brinda Karat, Ajay Maken, Sandeep Dikshit and activists Yogendra Yadav, Umar Khalid were among over 1,200 people detained from areas around Red Fort and Mandi House — the sites of the two planned demonstrations.

Notwithstanding the restrictions, hundreds of flag-waving students and activists converged near the historic Jantar Mantar in the afternoon to voice their anger against the contentious law after police forcefully evicted protesters from areas around Red Fort and Mandi House. Permission for holding any demonstration in the two sites was not granted.

In the evening, more protesters joined at Janpath, to further protest.

A video from the location shows protesters against CAA come face-to-face with Delhi Police, who had direct orders to detain anyone. In the video, the protesters can be heard singing 'Hum honge kamiyaab,' (We shall overcome) and then, the national anthem.

At the sound of the national anthem, both he police and the protesters stood at the same place, unified for a moment. Watch the video below.
 
ꯃꯥꯀꯨ (@porbotialora) Tweeted:
Reang refugees have been living in camps in Tripura since 1997-98 when they were evicted out of their homes for not converting to Christianity.

Only those that agree to convert and become Mizo are allowed to stay.

Full video: Refugees in their own country - Reangs in Relief Camp Tripura ꯃꯥꯀꯨ on Twitter ( )
I usually avoid speaking ill of my own countrymen. But sometimes it cant be helped. I've seen a few comments about the Assam NRC by some Assamese posters on D. F. I.
The common theme was "We don't want to be another Tripura". I've refrained from commenting there as I don't post much there anyway. But allow me to add my two paisa.

"We don't want to be another Tripura" is a general thing said by all NE states to different degrees. Assam and Mizoram being the virulent of all of them. This sentence is repeated over and over not because they really understand Tripura's history or that they are even interested. They say this as a half-baked political anthem fed to them by their leadership. One common point they bring up is how the Kokborak language has died at the hands of a foreign language(Bengali). Oddly enough they don't seem to know or care when Bengali was introduced in the state. The exact dates are disputed but it was with the crowning of the King Ratna Manikya around the year 1280 CE, the onset of the Manakya dynasty. The king sought to do more trade with the Bengal provinces to our west(present day Bangladesh), so he struck a deal, we were to be given access to the sea and in return Bengal would be allowed to trade in the state. Trade flourished and our people became more prosperous. Soon enough the King sought to open teaching centres for learning the Bengali language, he thought this would open up avenues of trade and partnership with Bengal that was previously not possible. It started small and it is believed the King himself was one of the learners there. The language spread with time, to the point where all the royals, ministers and people in high places spoke the language.

A case in point would be Sachin Deb Burman. A member of the royal family who gained such popularity for his songs in Bengali and Hindi that he became a national icon. Oh and he was born in Comilla, just to give an idea of the people-to-people relations we had with Bengal. Of course SD Burman was born some 600+ years later after the King Ratna Manikya. With in this time the language grew to such extent that it eclipsed the native Kokborak. Then came the onslaught of refugees around the 1970s with the Bangladesh liberation war. The balance of linguistics and political power tipped greatly towards the Bengalis, much to the dislike of the Tripuris. This will in turn bring the insurgency/terrorist attacks in Tripura. I have written about those before.

I understand the concern that the Kokborak language is being lost. I understand the concern that the Tripuri culture is being lost. I also understand that people think its an unfair deal. In exchange for the relation with the Bengalis we were promised access to the sea, better connectivity to the world. But partition of Bengal took that away from us.

Who do we blame for that ?
The old King ? He was merely trying to make his people and his kingdom more prosperous.

The partition which we had nothing to do with but we suffered greatly for it. Who do we blame for that ? The Bengalis ? We suffered economically, they were slaughtered left and right.

The loss of popularity of Kokborak ? The education system ? The educators were trying to get our kids to learn a language that would be economically beneficial. First it was Bengali now its English. Most of our people speak at least 2-3 languages today.

The tipping of political power ? The Bengali refugees ? Weren't they getting slaughtered by Muslims in the erstwhile East Pakistan.

The insurgency and political violence by the Tripuris ? Largely created by a vacuum of leadership with some foreign instigation.

The point is people have suffered quite a lot. And to make matters worse Delhi's general attitude towards developing the NE until recently has been "Why bother ? China will invade it anyway". We don't have a lot of people/voters/seats, thus our voices don't matter a lot to Delhi. We don't matter much, I know. But even with all that we've made it work. We've reduced insurgency to nothing and increased literacy rates to one of the highest in the country. We did all that while getting a fraction of the resources that Assam. Assam is big and it matters politically, thus get get the resources and the attention. The likes of Sikkim can become a tourist destination to gather resources, we can't because of connectivity problems. Nagaland, Manipur and Mizoram have sold their souls to the evangelist in exchange of money, we won't do that either. So what's left then ? Work hard, break your back to earn meager sums of money, what else ? That's what we did, that's what we have to continue doing.

Every time I come across someone from the NE, I get this condescending attitude from them. One poster in D. F. I. was going on about how our CM has relations with Bangladesh. I don't like Biplab Kr. Deb, never did. But this is a bit insulting don't you think ? This comes from the same Assam that is still fighting the Bodo militants even with all the resources from Delhi. We aren't great, I know. But you folks are hardly qualified to judge us.

The less said about the Mizos the better. They prosecuted their own blood because they weren't Christians. To expect them to have better thoughts about us seems a bit much.

Sorry for the rant. Couldn't help it.
 
I usually avoid speaking ill of my own countrymen. But sometimes it cant be helped. I've seen a few comments about the Assam NRC by some Assamese posters on D. F. I.
The common theme was "We don't want to be another Tripura". I've refrained from commenting there as I don't post much there anyway. But allow me to add my two paisa.

"We don't want to be another Tripura" is a general thing said by all NE states to different degrees. Assam and Mizoram being the virulent of all of them. This sentence is repeated over and over not because they really understand Tripura's history or that they are even interested. They say this as a half-baked political anthem fed to them by their leadership. One common point they bring up is how the Kokborak language has died at the hands of a foreign language(Bengali). Oddly enough they don't seem to know or care when Bengali was introduced in the state. The exact dates are disputed but it was with the crowning of the King Ratna Manikya around the year 1280 CE, the onset of the Manakya dynasty. The king sought to do more trade with the Bengal provinces to our west(present day Bangladesh), so he struck a deal, we were to be given access to the sea and in return Bengal would be allowed to trade in the state. Trade flourished and our people became more prosperous. Soon enough the King sought to open teaching centres for learning the Bengali language, he thought this would open up avenues of trade and partnership with Bengal that was previously not possible. It started small and it is believed the King himself was one of the learners there. The language spread with time, to the point where all the royals, ministers and people in high places spoke the language.

A case in point would be Sachin Deb Burman. A member of the royal family who gained such popularity for his songs in Bengali and Hindi that he became a national icon. Oh and he was born in Comilla, just to give an idea of the people-to-people relations we had with Bengal. Of course SD Burman was born some 600+ years later after the King Ratna Manikya. With in this time the language grew to such extent that it eclipsed the native Kokborak. Then came the onslaught of refugees around the 1970s with the Bangladesh liberation war. The balance of linguistics and political power tipped greatly towards the Bengalis, much to the dislike of the Tripuris. This will in turn bring the insurgency/terrorist attacks in Tripura. I have written about those before.

I understand the concern that the Kokborak language is being lost. I understand the concern that the Tripuri culture is being lost. I also understand that people think its an unfair deal. In exchange for the relation with the Bengalis we were promised access to the sea, better connectivity to the world. But partition of Bengal took that away from us.

Who do we blame for that ?
The old King ? He was merely trying to make his people and his kingdom more prosperous.

The partition which we had nothing to do with but we suffered greatly for it. Who do we blame for that ? The Bengalis ? We suffered economically, they were slaughtered left and right.

The loss of popularity of Kokborak ? The education system ? The educators were trying to get our kids to learn a language that would be economically beneficial. First it was Bengali now its English. Most of our people speak at least 2-3 languages today.

The tipping of political power ? The Bengali refugees ? Weren't they getting slaughtered by Muslims in the erstwhile East Pakistan.

The insurgency and political violence by the Tripuris ? Largely created by a vacuum of leadership with some foreign instigation.

The point is people have suffered quite a lot. And to make matters worse Delhi's general attitude towards developing the NE until recently has been "Why bother ? China will invade it anyway". We don't have a lot of people/voters/seats, thus our voices don't matter a lot to Delhi. We don't matter much, I know. But even with all that we've made it work. We've reduced insurgency to nothing and increased literacy rates to one of the highest in the country. We did all that while getting a fraction of the resources that Assam. Assam is big and it matters politically, thus get get the resources and the attention. The likes of Sikkim can become a tourist destination to gather resources, we can't because of connectivity problems. Nagaland, Manipur and Mizoram have sold their souls to the evangelist in exchange of money, we won't do that either. So what's left then ? Work hard, break your back to earn meager sums of money, what else ? That's what we did, that's what we have to continue doing.

Every time I come across someone from the NE, I get this condescending attitude from them. One poster in D. F. I. was going on about how our CM has relations with Bangladesh. I don't like Biplab Kr. Deb, never did. But this is a bit insulting don't you think ? This comes from the same Assam that is still fighting the Bodo militants even with all the resources from Delhi. We aren't great, I know. But you folks are hardly qualified to judge us.

The less said about the Mizos the better. They prosecuted their own blood because they weren't Christians. To expect them to have better thoughts about us seems a bit much.

Sorry for the rant. Couldn't help it.

You are from Tripura?? Glad you gotthe pride. Dont worry, good days are going to come for the patriots soon.

Enlighten me abou the Bodos though, I thought the bodos were natives who took to armed overthrough of the immigrants who became majority in their state and wanted a separate state for themselves??
 
You are from Tripura??
Born and raised here.
Enlighten me abou the Bodos though, I thought the bodos were natives who took to armed overthrough of the immigrants who became majority in their state and wanted a separate state for themselves??
I think the Assamese can tell you about that better than me. A lot of the insurgencies in NE started with language and demographics but later morphed into something else altogether. A lot of them got support from abroad. In case of the Bodo and some others support came from China. In Tripura our insurgents got support from the Baptist Church of New Zealand and some Maoists from West Bengal and Jharkhand. All of the supporters have their own independent, sometimes conflicting motivations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CountryFirst
The title of this thread is weird and politically tilted.

"Opposition outcry"?????

Are you friggin kidding me?!!!!!

We are on slow burn ... AND THE FUSE IS RUNNING OUT!

Cheers, Doc
 
This is what woke is. They've no clue as to the contents of the act, nor do they have any inclination to find out nor are they aware of the context & history behind it. Furthermore, this government doesn't believe in sharing information and preparing the ground to cultivate & propogate favourable opinion much like what happened at Balakote & it's aftermath. Result the opposition to what's essentially a necessary & altruistic Act is being censured all around. They haven't even highlighted that most of those whom this act would benefit are overwhelmingly from the backward & Dalit castes.These are times when ppl like Arun Jaitley & Sushma Swaraj will be most missed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nikhil
This is what woke is. They've no clue as to the contents of the act, nor do they have any inclination to find out nor are they aware of the context & history behind it. Furthermore, this government doesn't believe in sharing information and preparing the ground to cultivate & propogate favourable opinion much like what happened at Balakote & it's aftermath. Result the opposition to what's essentially a necessary & altruistic Act is being censured all around. They haven't even highlighted that most of those whom this act would benefit are overwhelmingly from the backward & Dalit castes.These are times when ppl like Arun Jaitley & Sushma Swaraj will be most missed.
Some part of the lack of information dissemination and doing some "soothing the nerves" before the bill was passed seems intentional. It just seems like the BJP knew the stone pelting and arson would happen and they will let it happen for a while. Seems like a consolidation exercise to me. How politically effective it will be remains to be seen, but there will be some degree of consolidation. Just my two cents.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nikhil
Some part of the lack of information dissemination and doing some "soothing the nerves" before the bill was passed seems intentional. It just seems like the BJP knew the stone pelting and arson would happen and they will let it happen for a while. Seems like a consolidation exercise to me. How politically effective it will be remains to be seen, but there will be some degree of consolidation. Just my two cents.
I doubt that was the intention. For if that's the case, the NRC will be far more problematic. OTOH it can well be argued that the GoI may well have considered this to be some sort of a test case to check the response and take adequate measures the next time. I'm of the opinion they anticipated problems in the NE & WB for obvious reasons but not mainland India especially Delhi. No matter, I hope the right lessons are drawn, adequate precautions taken when the NRC is implemented which I hope isn't any time soon. It's time this GoI pulls the economy by its bootstraps. Wonder how much of the current unrest is due to a flagging economy.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Nikhil and Gautam
Know The Nation (@knowthenation) Tweeted:
“CAA is discriminatory against women who get married and change their surnames multiple times!”

Shocking levels of misinformation was found prevalent among youngsters especially girls.

This was at Mumbai August Kranti Maidan #CAA_NRC_Protests had

#ISupportCAA_NRC Know The Nation on Twitter ( )


I always had my doubts on the level of intelligence of our student community which given our education standards, we'd never be able to elevate. A good example out here is @Guynextdoor
Know The Nation (@knowthenation) Tweeted:
“CAA is discriminatory against women who get married and change their surnames multiple times!”

Shocking levels of misinformation was found prevalent among youngsters especially girls.

This was at Mumbai August Kranti Maidan #CAA_NRC_Protests had

#ISupportCAA_NRC Know The Nation on Twitter ( )


I always had my doubts on the level of intelligence of our student community which given our education standards, we'd never be able to elevate. A good example out here is @Guynextdoor
 
Minhaz Merchant (@MinhazMerchant) Tweeted:
#BJP’s poor communications protocol exposed again & again as #CAA_NRC_Protests escalate. Senior political leaders & law enforcement officers should be giving daily briefings on the steps being taken to control the violence & explaining details of #CAA with infographics ( )