They manufacture/assemble seekers.What secret project are they working on? Barak-8 ER?
They manufacture/assemble seekers.What secret project are they working on? Barak-8 ER?
For the Barak-8 family, I know. But that's old news. Why are they given this status now. What new secret projects will they execute?They manufacture/assemble seekers.
Possibly due to Spice, Spike atgm local production etc related future involvement? They have few new business lines opening https://www.bharatforge.com/assets/...sults/asia-roadshow-presentation-mar-fy23.pdfFor the Barak-8 family, I know. But that's old news. Why are they given this status now. What new secret projects will they execute?
Bharat Forge is making the 76 mm naval gun. I assume it is the OTO Melara 76 mm that BHEL also manufactures under license. BHEL has got some competition then. I wonder if Bharat Forge has a separate licensing agreement with the Italians or is it an extension of the same agreement they have with BHEL.
Must watch
Both guns are indigenous developments under MAKE 1 procedure, not licensed production from Italy or anyone.Bharat Forge is making the 76 mm naval gun. I assume it is the OTO Melara 76 mm that BHEL also manufactures under license. BHEL has got some competition then. I wonder if Bharat Forge has a separate licensing agreement with the Italians or is it an extension of the same agreement they have with BHEL.
Baba Kalyani also says they are getting into making 127 mm naval main guns. He doesn't say if they are going for their own design or is it a license with a foreign OEM.
The last time the Navy put out a tender for a 127mm gun there are 2 main contenders:
1. BAE Systems Mk 45 Mod 4 naval main gun
2. Otobreda 127mm 64 cal naval main gun.
The Italians won the contest & signed a licensing agreement with BHEL to manufacture the guns in India. Then Leonardo got blacklisted. So, the Navy negotiated with BAE, who demanded an exorbitant price for those guns. So, the Navy just went back to their 76mm. That's why our large naval ships don't have a 127 mm main gun.
Recently, Leonardo was removed from the blacklist. The Navy definitely favors the Otobreda over the Mk45. I was wondering how this might go from here. Will the Navy call a separate tender again or will they activate the dormant BHEL license agreement? From the looks of it, the Navy is doing the later.
So where does Bharat Forge fit in this arrangement? Maybe both BHEL & BF will produce these guns under license & the Navy will pick the better manufacturer to order from.
The 1st ships to receive these guns would probably be the Shivalik class frigate when they are sent for their MLUs.
We need a level playing field with PSU shipyards.Can not blame, psu shipyards can lay docks sit idle, they can't. People say we need more shipyards, first need to use the full capacity with more orders then think about expansion.
PSUs are literally rigged such way to favour each other in such ways it will never be possible under current process. PSUs are essentially a tool of the govt. Then there is one demanding user who want anything everything custom fitted on the same platform without thinking twice about commonality. Result is long delay between projects and unwillingness to let private sector that is big enough/on par get the projects.We need a level playing field with PSU shipyards.
Things have changed drastically, these shipyards are no longer just tools of government (except HSL). They have became corporate and answerable to shareholders. And the user no longer changes design in midway unless it's a new risky design like NGD. Most of the designs of smaller ships are done between MSMEs and shipyards (Biggest example is new tanker).PSUs are literally rigged such way to favour each other in such ways it will never be possible under current process. PSUs are essentially a tool of the govt. Then there is one demanding user who want anything everything custom fitted on the same platform without thinking twice about commonality. Result is long delay between projects and unwillingness to let private sector that is big enough/on par get the projects.
This was likely army wanting this system for benchmarking imo , rather than they peddling. You need a good experience on a standard mobile shorad before establishing own sop and future domestic option.
Have got time to watch completely, very nicely done.