News India’s Bad Loans: News and Discussions

ArcelorMittal repays Essar Steel lenders, Rs 40,000 crore transferred to SBI
An excruciating 863-day wait has finally come to an end for the lenders of Essar Steel, with ArcelorMittal repaying the promised Rs 42,000 crore to them on Friday, banking executives privy to the developments told CNBC-TV18.

ArcelorMittal, the world’s biggest steelmaker, on Friday transferred a sum of about Rs 40,000 crore to the current account of Essar Steel's lead banker, State Bank of India to take over the debt-ridden company under the new Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, the executives told CNBC-TV18, requesting anonymity.

All creditors’ dues will be settled by the top lender by Monday (December 16), according to a senior banking executive who wished to remain anonymous.

Banks are set to recover over 90 percent of their claims against Essar Steel, amounting to over 40,000 crore — the single biggest recovery under IBC for banks so far. The operational creditors are set to get Rs 196 crore proposed by ArcelorMittal, run by billionaire Laxmi Mittal, plus another Rs 1,000 crore later allowed by the creditors' committee, taking the total repayment to Rs 1,196 crore.

The repayment comes almost a month after the November 15th Supreme Court verdict, which paved the way for Arcelor to take over Essar Steel and also upheld the primacy of financial creditors over other classes of creditors.

What Banks Will Recover
Sl NoBank Admitted ClaimsCoC Approved Distribution
1SBIRs 13,226 croreRs 12,161 crore2IDBI BankRs 2,481 croreRs 2,282 crore3Canara BankRs 3,798 croreRs 3,493 crore4Edelweiss ARC (HDFC Bank)Rs 602 croreRs 554 crore5Edelweiss ARC (Federal Bank)Rs 92 croreRs 84 crore6Edelweiss ARC (ICICI Bank)Rs 1,697 croreRs 1,561 crore7Edelweiss ARC (Axis Bank)Rs 993 croreRs 913 crore8Edelweiss ARC (Indian Overseas Bank)Rs 1,966 croreRs 1,808 crore9Edelweiss ARC (J&K Bank)Rs 554 croreRs 510 crore10Edelweiss ARC (Laxmi Vilas Bank)Rs 137 croreRs 126 crore11Edelweiss ARC (Bank of Baroda)Rs 1,237 croreRs 1,171 crore12Edelweiss ARC (HDFC Ltd )Rs 978 croreRs 900 crore13Edelweiss ARC (Bank of Baroda)Rs 10 croreRs 9 crore14Standard Chartered BankRs 3,557 croreRs 60.71 crore15Bank of BarodaRs 5 croreRs 4.6 crore16PNBRs 2,936 croreRs 2,701 crore17Deutsche Bank AGRs 2,829 croreRs 2,603 crore18ICICI BankRs 2,294 croreRs 2,110 crore19Union Bank of IndiaRs 2,122 croreRs 1,952 crore20Bank of IndiaRs 1,985 croreRs 1,826 crore21Corporation BankRs 1,566 croreRs 1,441 crore22Syndicate BankRs 967 croreRs 890 crore23UCO BankRs 582 croreRs 535 crore24EXIM BankRs 556 croreRs 511 crore25Central BankRs 510 croreRs 469 crore26Allahabad BankRs 320 croreRs 294 crore27SREI Indra FinanceRs 175 croreRs 161 crore



** Banks will collectively have to set aside Rs 1,000 crore in total from the above CoC approved distribution amount for operational creditors

While ArcelorMittal had kept the entire Rs 42,000 crore amount to be repaid in an escrow account, it did not immediately release it to the lenders after the November 15 Supreme Court order. This is because the European steel-maker had sought immunity for the Essar Steel asset from any ongoing cases against its promoters, the Ruias, and wanted to avoid the situation Jindals had found themselves in after the Bhushan Power takeover, a person familiar with the matter told CNBC-TV18.

However, the recent amendment to the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code that ring-fences the successful bidders of stressed assets from any criminal proceedings against offences committed by previous management/promoters gave ArcelorMittal the confidence to go ahead with the transaction, added the person quoted above.

As per the creditors committee approved plan which was upheld by the Supreme Court in its November 15 ruling, SBI will receive the largest chunk at Rs 12,161 crore, IDBI Bank Rs 2,282 crore, Canara Bank Rs 3,493 crore, ICICI Bank Rs 2,110 crore, Union Bank of India Rs 1,952 crore and Bank of India Rs 1,826 crore, said people familiar with the matter. Lenders, however, will set aside a total of Rs 1,000 crore additionally from their kitty for the operational creditors, as agreed by them earlier this year.

In a related development, lenders have also issued a Letter of Intent to ArcelorMittal for Odisha Slurry Pipeline Infra Ltd (OSPIL), a critical asset for Essar Steel plant, which connects its iron ore beneficiation plant in Dabuna with its pellet plant in Paradip, one of the people quoted above-told CNBC-TV18.

Essar Steel owes around Rs 49,046 crore to the financial creditors. SBI has an exposure of Rs 13,222 crore to the company, excluding the working capital it has been extending to the company during resolution process which is nearing closure after two-and-a-half years since going to the Ahmedabad bench of the bankruptcy tribunal in June 2017.

Essar Steel was among the first list of the largest 12 stressed accounts that the Reserve Bank of India had drawn up in June 2017 and asked banks to refer to the NCLT and the company was formally sent to the tribunal on June 27 2017.

As per the October 2018 resolution plan, secured financial creditors would recover 92 percent or around Rs 42,000 crore of their total exposure of Rs 49,046 crore.

Following this, the Ruias-run Essar Steel Asia Holding made a counter-offer to pay the entire amount in cash to bankers-a whopping Rs 54,389 crore but was rejected the NCLT in January 2019. After this on March 8, the NCLT approved ArcelorMittal's Rs 42000 crore bid.

On November 15, the Supreme Court had set aside the NCLAT order which gave equal rights to both secured and unsecured creditors of Essar Steel and cleared the decks for its takeover by ArcelorMittal.

A three-judge bench of RF Nariman said the two sets of creditors would be treated differently in any insolvency proceeding. There is no principle of equality between secured and unsecured creditors, the bench had said.

The NCLAT had said secured and unsecured creditors would get 60.7 percent of their dues from ArcelorMittal, which was challenged by banks in the apex court.
ArcelorMittal repays Essar Steel lenders, Rs 40,000 crore transferred to SBI
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bali78
How bankruptcy got redefined in India
On 16 December, the day it closed its acquisition of Essar Steel India Ltd, ArcelorMittal SA, the world’s largest steel company and the new owner of the steel mill, held a closing party at The Oberoi in Mumbai. The prevalent mood was one of relief. A collective sigh was almost palpable.

It had taken two years to get to that evening, involving courtroom battles in Ahmedabad and higher benches in New Delhi, and then the Supreme Court. Over those two years, there had been nearly 30 meetings of the Committee of Creditors (CoC), while its core committee—which recommended key decisions to the larger group—had met over a hundred times.

Aditya Mittal, the chairman of ArcelorMittal Nippon Steel India Ltd, has spent over two decades working with his father and steel magnate L.N. Mittal, training in the elder Mittal’s strategy of buying quality but distressed steel mills across the world and reorganizing them into productive businesses. This acquisition of Essar Steel—hailed as a triumphant homecoming of the Mittals after several false starts—was driven almost entirely by Aditya Mittal. He had set up a large cross-functional team out of ArcelorMittal Belgium, while also spending considerable time in India, liaising with lenders, and attending every ruling on the case at the Supreme Court.

In a country where the idea of bankruptcy is still nascent and the legal process to wind down a business while paying back lenders is still riddled with all manner of uncertainty and doubt, perhaps that level of devotion is necessary. A member of Essar Steel’s CoC recounted his conversation with the Mittal scion that evening at The Oberoi. “Aditya told me that when he first saw the Essar Steel asset, he straightaway fell in love with it. He said his love was just a tad lower than his love for his wife."

But love doesn’t come cheap, or even easy. ArcelorMittal, along with joint venture partner Nippon Steel Corp. of Japan, had paid ₹42,000 crore to win over those who had lent money to the erstwhile owners of the steel plant. Another ₹7,469 crore was shelled out just to qualify for the bid. (The latter was used to repay debts of Uttam Galva Steels Ltd and KSS Petron Pvt. Ltd, bankrupt firms with tangential links to the Mittals.) They had also committed to a capital infusion of ₹8,000 crore into the plant after taking over as the new owners.

The questions at the end of this long ordeal, in what was perhaps India’s most high-profile, big-ticket bankruptcy resolution, are: will the many cases that swirled through the country’s court system as a result of this distress sale radically change how business exits unfold? Will it result in more certainty for creditors? And will it lead to more money getting pumped into Indian businesses?

Evolution of IBC

When Standard Chartered Bank and State Bank of India filed insolvency proceedings against Essar Steel in August 2017, the company had an outstanding debt of ₹54,550 crore. It was the single biggest defaulter on the Reserve Bank of India is India’s original “dirty dozen" list of bad loans. Banks, which were laden with bad loans that were eating into their profits and starving them of capital, were going to test the new Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), which had been passed in Parliament the previous year.

The law was clear in what it wanted to achieve—quick resolution and maximum value recovery. But IBC also had a history of failed insolvency laws to contend with— the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (SICA), and the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Securities Interest Act, 2002 (Sarfaesi). Bankruptcy in India had always been a mess and lenders knew they could do little more than kiss their money goodbye.

It’s still early days, but IBC might change that. A second member of the Essar Steel CoC told Mint, on condition of anonymity, “If the Essar case didn’t happen, the danger of IBC going the SICA way would have been greater. But with Essar, we got such an eye-catching weighty deal, and there were bidders competing for it."

JSW Steel Ltd and Vedanta Ltd had also made overtures for the asset, while Mauritius-based Numetal fought ArcelorMittal’s bid tooth and nail all the way till the Supreme Court. The reason for the pitched battle is simple. While the Indian economy may be in the midst of a slowdown, much hope rides on its long-term prospects. And India currently has per capita steel consumption of only 70kg a year, less than half the average of many other developing nations. Due to a confluence of such factors, steel emerged as the unlikely test bed for India’s new bankruptcy law.

“Nobody could brush this case aside," said the CoC member quoted above. “It was a lot of money coming back into the banking system and the government was forced to sit up and take notice. Look at how many amendments have come from the Cabinet and the number of landmark judgments from the Supreme Court that have come through in the course of this case. I could see the change myself in other insolvent companies, where promoters were watching the Essar Steel resolution, and they realized that losing their businesses was now a real possibility."

The long turnaround

Alvarez and Marsal (A&M), turnaround management experts who were appointed as the resolution professional adviser in this case, dedicated a team of 25-30 people, at varying times, to Essar Steel.

Nikhil Shah, managing director at A&M India, who leads the turnaround practice, said: “At the start, the company didn’t have sufficient working capital to continue operations as all the critical suppliers said they would stop supplying goods and services unless they were paid in advance, because they didn’t want to take additional credit risk. We met the top 30 suppliers to assure them that Essar Steel was a going concern and that payments would be made on time. We had to build back the company’s credibility. Due to these efforts, over two plus years of the case, the plant saw operational expenditure of over ₹55,000 crore."

Nandini Chopra, MD at A&M India who leads the corporate finance practice, was tasked with finding buyers for the steel business, one of the largest in India. Chopra carried out an extensive outreach that covered most global steel manufacturers in the US, Europe, China, Russia, Brazil, Japan, South Korea and the large domestic firms.

There were repeated site visits, probably the most massive gatherings the small Gujarati town of Hazira, where the steel mill is based, has seen in quite some time.

Unlike most other steel plants in India, which are often based near iron ore reserves, the bulk of which is in the eastern part of the country, the Essar Steel plant is a 9.6 million-tonne single-location flat steel unit in Gujarat. But the Ruia family—the original owners—had built an ecosystem around the plant that was efficient enough to make the plant cost-competitive. They had built a 253km slurry pipeline from iron ore mines in Dabuna (Odisha) to a pellet plant in the coastal town of Paradip. These pellets were then shipped around to Hazira, where the Ruias operated a port terminal adjacent to the steel mill. For prospective bidders, this arrangement was a cause for worry. Only the steel plant was on sale in the deal, not the supporting infrastructure.

“To address this uncertainty," Shah said, “we gave them as much information about the inter-dependency and the criticality of that inter-dependency between these different assets. We said that if they couldn’t use the Hazira port, the nearby Adani port was an alternative. The most critical asset was the slurry pipeline. There were worries that someone else would acquire that which would impair the recovery value of Essar Steel."

This month, ArcelorMittal emerged as the highest bidder for this pipeline, offering lenders upfront cash of ₹2,200 crore to extinguish all outstanding debt.

Landmark court rulings

Through the Essar Steel case, courts gave several key rulings which cleared the grey areas at the edge of IBC. Section 29A was included in the code in 2017 to prevent defaulting promoters from buying back their assets for cheap. But the wording of the section also barred bidders with links to other defaulting assets. This hugely complicated the bidder vetting process for A&M India, which had to examine accounts of nearly 3,000 legal entities linked to the three top bidders. At the end of this process, ArcelorMittal and Numetal were both found ineligible. ArcelorMittal settled this by paying off dues of Uttam Galva and KSS Petron, but the court’s judgement proved fatal for Numetal, which couldn’t erase traces of its links to the Ruias in its bidding consortium.

The courts also later turned down an offer from the Ruia family under Section 12A to pay back all dues to lenders in full and withdraw the case from IBC, establishing a cut-off date for future resolution cases. Finally, after ArcelorMittal had been declared the winning bidder, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal threw a spanner in the works, ruling that secured financial creditors should be treated on a par with unsecured operational creditors when distributing resolution proceeds. This would have drastically reduced the recovery for banks, paid out more to operational creditors and shaken the very foundations of project finance in the country. In November, the apex court again stepped in to calm the storm, and upheld the supremacy of financial creditors over other classes of lenders.

“One of the outstanding things in the Essar Steel case is the promptness with which the Supreme Court has settled legal questions," said Sitesh Mukherjee, partner and head of disputes at Trilegal. “The court showed a lot of commercial awareness—and this is something commercial courts in India need to display— about the major points of bankruptcy resolution."

Satish Kumar Gupta, Chairman of Monitoring Committee and resolution professional, Essar Steel, said: “Essar Steel has been a challenging and complex resolution process and during its course, a number of legal precedents have been set. CoC along with executive management of Essar Steel has performed its role remarkably under ‘creditors- in-control’ regime to take suitable measures to enhance overall value of Essar Steel. Most of key management team has been retained by ArcelorMittal which shows their confidence in capability of management team of Essar Steel. It has turned out to be a great outcome for creditors and for IBC as a transparent resolution framework for stressed assets gains a lot of credibility with Indian and global investors."

Still miles to go

The Essar case apart, IBC has hardly been a runaway success. But it has at least brought in some much-needed credit discipline, something its predecessors were unable to achieve. In May this year, on the third anniversary of IBC, credit rating agency Crisil Ltd estimated that recovery through the IBC process was roughly ₹70,000 crore in FY19, or twice the ₹35,500 crore recovered through other resolution mechanisms such as the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT), Sarfaesi Act and the Lok Adalat in FY18.

More importantly, almost ₹2.02 trillion of debt pertaining to 4,452 cases had been disposed of even before admission into the IBC process, as borrowers made good the amounts in default to the creditors. The rate at which non-performing assets were piling up on banks’ balance sheets slowed as well. “The ultimate lesson for us bankers is that if we want to recover money, we need assets on the ground," said the second CoC member.

While a lot has been achieved through the Essar Steel case, there are still big legal questions within IBC that need clarity.

“I believe the next big question that needs to be tested in courts under IBC is whether the new owner of an asset gets immunity from the Prevention of Money Laundering Act," said the second CoC member quoted above. JSW Steel’s resolution plan to take over bankrupt Bhushan Power and Steel Ltd (BSPL) is stuck in courts on this very question, where some of BPSL’s assets have been attached by the Enforcement Directorate as part of fraud investigations into its erstwhile promoter Sanjay Singal. “While the Cabinet has already amended the IBC to give resolution applicants this immunity, the proof of the pudding is in the eating," said the first CoC member.

Lawyers that Mint spoke to said IBC still needs to clarify how government licences and concessions of insolvent companies should be dealt with. Another is the question of personal guarantees given by promoters. Earlier, these were enforceable at DRTs but now banks can combine them under the IBC case for bankrupt firms.

Meanwhile, the battle for Essar Steel doesn’t seem to have fazed the Mittals. The first CoC member had also met ArcelorMittal owner L.N. Mittal, at The Oberoi party. “LN Mittal said that when he acquired Arcelor, he had to work with four-five heads of state, including France’s (Jacques) Chirac and (Valdimir) Putin in Russia. He closed that deal in six months. Essar took 866 days. But the two years was worth it. It laid the foundations for IBC, not just for us with Essar but for everybody else."
How bankruptcy got redefined in India
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gautam
Times of India (@timesofindia) Tweeted:
‘Karma’ catches up with one of India’s most storied families

The tumultuous saga of former billionaires Malvinder and Shivinder Singh seems to be entering a decisive stage.

Read: ‘Karma’ catches up with one of India’s most storied families - Times of India Times of India on Twitter ( )

Wow, what a bunch of fools to blow away $2 billion each in less than a decade
 
  • Agree
Reactions: _Anonymous_
India may finally have a bad bank to deal with NPAs amid COVID-19 blues
Indian banks are in the initial stages of considering creating a bad bank to deal with bad loans, the chief of the country's top lender confirmed to CNBC-TV18.

"These are some initial thoughts at the IBA level and by many members in IBA," Rajnish Kumar, CMD of SBI told CNBC-TV18 in an interview, referring to the Indian Bank Association. "We believe that this is the right time where a structure along the lines of a bad bank can be worked out because the provisions on the existing NPAs - most of the banks are holding a very high level of provisions."

Kumar's comments come in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic, which is expected to result in a rise in NPAs of banks despite a number of relief steps taken by the RBI, including allowing a 90-day moratorium on retail loans and relaxing working capital financing norms.

A bad bank structure has long been discussed in India's policy circles to deal with the high level of non-performing assets (NPAs) that have hobbled banks for years, bogging down credit and economic growth.

The SBI chief's comments suggest that the bad bank could be an industry effort -- perhaps through the creation of an asset reconstruction company (ARC)-cum-asset management company (AMC) -- rather than one implemented by the government.

Bad bank structures are typically suggested to be modelled on the TARP programme implemented by the US government during the 2008 financial crisis.

Kumar said that the idea of bad bank was not feasible three years ago, when talk began that banks should spin off bad assets into a separate company to unburden existing banks.

"The provisions were inadequate. Today, at least we have the adequate provisions and net book value is hardly 10-15% of the gross NPAs," he said.

The SBI chief stated that these discussions were at a very early stage.

"Once the approach and a consensus emerges between all the banks, then only [we will look at the] next moves -- whether we need to take some external regulatory dispensation or do we need some support from the government, whether the government support will come or not come. All these are open issues."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gautam