Is there any point in the MTCR

BMD

Senior member
Dec 4, 2017
29,912
5,260
If Iran can supply Houthi rebels with 2100km missiles, what is the point in the MTCR?

 
  • Agree
Reactions: RASALGHUL
Iran isn't a member of MTCR, Right??
WE should incentivize Iran to join it.
Maybe Resign Nuclear-deal with Iran.
 
If Iran can supply Houthi rebels with 2100km missiles, what is the point in the MTCR?


It's doesn't really apply to pariah states or near-pariah states.

Instead of Iraq, the US should have attacked Iran.
 
It's doesn't really apply to pariah states or near-pariah states.
Well that's the problem. The INF, MTCR and NPT have all recently proven to be shite, in that they've allowed terrible regimes to continue doing exactly what they were designed to stop, while better regimes live with their limitations. It's basically like a system of civil law where only the criminals end up with firearms.
Instead of Iraq, the US should have attacked Iran.
There was no sound justification for attacking Iran. Yes it was a shite regime (no pun intended), but they'd never invaded a neighbour, nor gassed civilians, nor were they a likely source for Al Quaeda recruitment due to Shia nature.
 
If Iran can supply Houthi rebels with 2100km missiles, what is the point in the MTCR?

sooner or later missiles will become ubiquitous like AK-47 (soviet scuds did that to some extend but they had limited ranged).
Very thing the west feared. Its one of the reason why US wanted to clamp down on technology transfer and also start building a comprehensive BMD.

Unlike AK-47 missiles will bring the war to your door step.
 
The INF, MTCR and NPT have all recently proven to be shite, in that they've allowed terrible regimes to continue doing exactly
No, these technology denial regimes were cobbled up to deny countries like India technology. They had some effect during the 90's and were useful if the countries were economically dependent. But rogue regimes have no such compulsion sooner or later they ended up gaining technology making these exclusive clubs thing of past.
 
????
Iran war would have been even more bloodier than iraq war.

They have Sino-Russia support, but more importantly, they can block off the Strait of Hormuz, which would drastically shoot up the price of oil.

Anyway, Iran wasn't a target because its geography doesn't immediately allow the US to checkmate Russia like Iraq and Syria can. It's why the Russians stepped into Syria. Basically the Black Sea is Russia's only access to warm waters, along with Syria. The Black Sea can be blocked off by Turkey, one of the reasons why the US gives so much importance to Turkey, another being Turkey's access to the Caspian via Georgia and Azerbaijan, which delivers gas to Europe.

Then of course, the next step was to take Syria away, so that would completely cut Russia off from any kind of warm water (water that doesn't freeze during winter, like the Arctic).

If the US succeeded, then all of Russia's trade would go through NATO-controlled waters, which would have made Russia subservient to the US. When that didn't work of course, they decided to use Ukraine as a patsy to sanction Russia, problem solved. All this circus because Germany was addicted to Russian gas, the idiots selling their soul one pipeline after the other feeding Russia's war chest.

Access to warm water is why the SU invaded Afghanistan, they had planned to go further south through Iran and Pakistan as well, until the US put a stop to it.
 
sooner or later missiles will become ubiquitous like AK-47 (soviet scuds did that to some extend but they had limited ranged).
Very thing the west feared. Its one of the reason why US wanted to clamp down on technology transfer and also start building a comprehensive BMD.

Unlike AK-47 missiles will bring the war to your door step.
They'll also make the response far bloodier though. If a country keeps firing ballistic missiles at European cities, it's likely going to get nuked until it stops.
No, these technology denial regimes were cobbled up to deny countries like India technology. They had some effect during the 90's and were useful if the countries were economically dependent. But rogue regimes have no such compulsion sooner or later they ended up gaining technology making these exclusive clubs thing of past.
Stop playing the martyr, they really weren't aimed at you at all. They were aimed at rogue regimes who did not possess the ability to produce such missiles themselves. The Houthis would be a prime example. That's basically a terrorist organisation that's being supplied with medium range missiles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RASALGHUL
They have Sino-Russia support, but more importantly, they can block off the Strait of Hormuz, which would drastically shoot up the price of oil.

Anyway, Iran wasn't a target because its geography doesn't immediately allow the US to checkmate Russia like Iraq and Syria can. It's why the Russians stepped into Syria. Basically the Black Sea is Russia's only access to warm waters, along with Syria. The Black Sea can be blocked off by Turkey, one of the reasons why the US gives so much importance to Turkey, another being Turkey's access to the Caspian via Georgia and Azerbaijan, which delivers gas to Europe.

Then of course, the next step was to take Syria away, so that would completely cut Russia off from any kind of warm water (water that doesn't freeze during winter, like the Arctic).

If the US succeeded, then all of Russia's trade would go through NATO-controlled waters, which would have made Russia subservient to the US. When that didn't work of course, they decided to use Ukraine as a patsy to sanction Russia, problem solved. All this circus because Germany was addicted to Russian gas, the idiots selling their soul one pipeline after the other feeding Russia's war chest.

Access to warm water is why the SU invaded Afghanistan, they had planned to go further south through Iran and Pakistan as well, until the US put a stop to it.
Kaliningrad doesn't freeze during winter either, that's why they wanted it.

How would Russia be exporting via Syria?

That quite possibly is why they invaded Afghanistan, it was part of Dugina's philosophy.

As for Ukraine, Russia made that problem for themselves. There are lots of better ways they could have handled it.
 
Stop playing the martyr, they really weren't aimed at you at all. They were aimed at rogue regimes who did not possess the ability to produce such missiles themselves. The Houthis would be a prime example. That's basically a terrorist organisation that's being supplied with medium range missiles.
🤣

MTCR was launched as a response to the growing missile programs of developing countries. This was targeted particularly at India to deny every advanced technology whether they were associated with missiles or not.

India was deliberately denied cryogenic technology bcos of MTCR to stunt its space program.

India was denied cray super computers ( that company went bust) when they wanted it for simulating weather forecasting. Recently they dint even want to share the covid vaccine but only after the uproar in the UN they had to agree to license its production.
 
Well that's the problem. The INF, MTCR and NPT have all recently proven to be shite, in that they've allowed terrible regimes to continue doing exactly what they were designed to stop, while better regimes live with their limitations. It's basically like a system of civil law where only the criminals end up with firearms.

INF worked, the US backed out to deal with China, they backed out of the ABM Treaty as well. MTCR was only meant to create an exclusive club of haves. NPT is a sham, the US allowed proliferation of nukes outside Pakistan because it suited their needs. One created the patsy necessary to keep India in check, the other put SoKo and Japan, the endless money making machines at the time, firmly under their thumb.

There was no sound justification for attacking Iran. Yes it was a shite regime (no pun intended), but they'd never invaded a neighbour, nor gassed civilians, nor were they a likely source for Al Quaeda recruitment due to Shia nature.

There was no justification to deal with Iraq and Syria either. Justification can be created.
 
🤣

MTCR was launched as a response to the growing missile programs of developing countries. This was targeted particularly at India to deny every advanced technology whether they were associated with missiles or not.

India was deliberately denied cryogenic technology bcos of MTCR to stunt its space program.

India was denied cray super computers ( that company went bust) when they wanted it for simulating weather forecasting. Recently they dint even want to share the covid vaccine but only after the uproar in the UN they had to agree to license its production.
If you read it in full, the MTCR was utterly irrelevant, since it was tech specific to space exploration not used in missiles.

At that point in time India already possessed missile technology well past that banned by the treaty, so again it's not relevant, regardless of whether an idiot politician tried to make it so.

Supercomputer export issue was in the 1980s, during the Cold War and after Indo-Soviet Treaty, which made it impossible, i.e. it's obvious where that tech would have ended up. This is probably the real reason they tried to block the space engine deal. They didn't like who you were in bed with, and likely still don't.

They were prioritising their own COVID issues.

 
No, these technology denial regimes were cobbled up to deny countries like India technology. They had some effect during the 90's and were useful if the countries were economically dependent. But rogue regimes have no such compulsion sooner or later they ended up gaining technology making these exclusive clubs thing of past.

Yep, both NPT and NSG were basically created to keep India out. The rest of the world could easily be kept out without either via diplomatic pressure.
 
INF worked, the US backed out to deal with China, they backed out of the ABM Treaty as well. MTCR was only meant to create an exclusive club of haves. NPT is a sham, the US allowed proliferation of nukes outside Pakistan because it suited their needs. One created the patsy necessary to keep India in check, the other put SoKo and Japan, the endless money making machines at the time, firmly under their thumb.
Nope, only two countries were involved and Russia broke it with at least two missiles before it was terminated, and likely several.

Iskander-M
Iskander-K

Bastion-P probably too. Equally Zircon - They would probably have just stated the range at less than 500km, maybe even less than 300km for export purposes.

What patsy? Pakistan? China is responsible for NK getting nukes, only they benefit.


There was no justification to deal with Iraq and Syria either. Justification can be created.
Disagree:

Iraq - The justification was blatant and it should have happened in 1991.

Syria - That was a democratic rebellion, don't blame NATO for it starting, or for current happenings in Iran. Bad regimes make people unhappy, simple as that.
 
Yep, both NPT and NSG were basically created to keep India out. The rest of the world could easily be kept out without either via diplomatic pressure.
Nope, the world does not revolve around India.
 
What ??? Can you explain more?
Like which countries didn't want india in NPT & NSG?? Also why??

NPT was created to prevent the SU from sharing nukes with other countries, of course, vice versa. It's very likely that the SU got pissed off, obviously, when they found out about America's nuclear sharing agreement with Europe.

NSG was created immediately after India's 1974 test. It was designed to keep India out of nuclear trade.

Right after the Sino-Soviet split in 1969, China became enemies with the SU, so the US helped China get back its UNSC seat in Nov 1971, basically after the India-SU Friendship Treaty. During that time Nixon absolutely hated India, plus China became friendly, so that's that.

Since China was India's enemy, plus a nuclear weapons state, plus friendly with the US, plus a UNSC power, India had to show resolve, and IG tested a nuke in 1974.

That's basically when India became a pariah state, a lot of technologies were denied to India after that, both nuclear and space tech. The SU stepped in with tech, and we decided to create our own nuclear military and space tech (India's Space Commission was set up in 1972).
 
  • Agree
Reactions: jetray