Indian supersonic missile reached Mian Channu in Pakistan : ISPR

And secondly, it's not about raw electronics, its also about the programmed electronics. The data which is fed in missile in encrypted first like communication frequencies, telemetry protocols. If they get their hands on communication frequency and are able to break the encrypted details then it's a threat to missile system and satellites as well through cyber attack.
Errr... Nope! Thats why I said, if DRDO have an ounce of wisdom (that is they are not complete and total idiots), it will be impossible to get any data out of chips in that missile. One word, SRAM. Nothing critical needs to be stored in the missile at all. Just load critical data at the time to fire (it hardly will take few millisecs more) and upon impact, the electornics loose power and become useless.

Since this is a missile that needs to fly 20 minutes max (Assuming 800 KM maximum range and 2 mach speed), entire "smart" electronics can be powered by capacitors (or at worst ultra caps) with only power electronics (radar amplifiers etc) powered by a battery. Meaning you can set a hard limit to when the critical electronics loose power.

Now if they are not carefully designed, sooner or later, Pakistan or China will get their hands on it. Best way to keep things secret is to have no long term secrets. Let the secret become useless before it can be exracted.
 
This wasn't a screw-up. It was a deliberate launch.

Missiles don't just get into launch positions and accidentally launch. The fact that the missile itself flew all that way says even a target was selected before the launch. Without a target, it's unlikely for it to launch either. Even the trajectory has to be pre-decided.

Missiles aren't like guns, you can't accidentally press the trigger and make it go off.
I am forcing myself to believe this but then I remind myself of totally unbelievable kind of incidences that have happened in the past. Like US nuclear silo door being kept open for long time and discovered by food delivery person... nuclear arming code being 0000000... US bomber dropping an almost armed H-Bomb on Texas (IIRC) with only a toggle switch preventing the detonation. Strange shit has happened in the past.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bonobashi
I am forcing myself to believe this but then I remind myself of totally unbelievable kind of incidences that have happened in the past. Like US nuclear silo door being kept open for long time and discovered by food delivery person... nuclear arming code being 0000000... US bomber dropping an almost armed H-Bomb on Texas (IIRC) with only a toggle switch preventing the detonation. Strange shit has happened in the past.

All of those are examples of human error. Launch protocol takes a long time to prep. One oops moment is fine, but many oops moments happening in a sequence is very hard to believe. The launch itself has at least one or more steps that require two people making the exact same "mistake" together at the very same time.
 
All of those are examples of human error. Launch protocol takes a long time to prep. One oops moment is fine, but many oops moments happening in a sequence is very hard to believe. The launch itself has at least one or more steps that require two people making the exact same "mistake" together at the very same time.
*Ahem* "Human Errors"? You know protocols do not come from heavens on a stone tablet. They are made by people too. If a US protocol deisnger overlooked 000000 as failsafe code, I am sure an Indian protocol designer can over-look a bypass to launch authentication code. If Americans are capable of dropping TWO armed nukes (with ALL THE SAFETIES failed) on Carolina I am sure Indians are capable of firing a Brahmos on Pakistan, by mistake.

I mean, by design, Titanic was NEVER expected to sink. By design Tepco power plant was never expected to meltdown. All had every protocols in place.

These are called tail events and they do happen. The ones told here are public domain ones. Devil knows what else have failed or almost failed in past. This is why I am not able to rule out sufficiently accident scenario.
 
Mach 2.9
Works out to 59 kms a minute (app)
Works out to a km a second.
The missile took seven minutes (18:43 to 18:50) from launch to final impact.
Not even enough time for air defence to react and take counter measures let alone scrambling fighter planes.... 😊

So Pakistanis now know that if India has launched a Brahmos or a salvo of Brahmos missiles they're f*ked... 😂🤣
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chain Smoker
Not even enough time for air defence to react and take counter measures let alone scrambling fighter planes.... 😊

So Pakistanis now know that if India has launched a Brahmos or a salvo of Brahmos missiles they're f*ked... 😂🤣
Yes.

You do realise that this sends up the possibility of unintentional nuclear war by a significant amount.

In future, any Brahmos attack, any attack by a fast-moving missile moving at nearly Mach 3 must be considered nuclear until proved otherwise.

That means that they will have NO option but to launch nuclear devices immediately on detection of an incoming missile.
 
Yes.

You do realise that this sends up the possibility of unintentional nuclear war by a significant amount.

In future, any Brahmos attack, any attack by a fast-moving missile moving at nearly Mach 3 must be considered nuclear until proved otherwise.

That means that they will have NO option but to launch nuclear devices immediately on detection of an incoming missile.
I disagree. 6-7 minutes is not enough time for them to erect their BMs. So they will ALWAYS have to wait that much before launching missile enough for this one to hit.

Basically, this one incidence does not change anything. If anything, it adds a doubtful scenario in the minds of decision makers. "Is this lone missile nuclear or like last time it is a blank or conventionally armed one". If anything it makes hair-trigger looser. That is, assuming Pakistani want to live.

BTW, it works for other side too.

In a weird kind of way, it makes perfect weapon to do lone Balakot kind of strikes.... May be thats the purpose of this "accident".... Who knows.
 

This doesn't seem like there was no warhead in the missile. Listen to what the content creator says. We've still no clue what the site was used for though charter on Twitter suggests it was a cold storage. What's a lathe doing there?

For more details on OSINT track the T/L of bennedose on Twitter . He's done good investigative work based on open source material.
 
Yes.

You do realise that this sends up the possibility of unintentional nuclear war by a significant amount.

In future, any Brahmos attack, any attack by a fast-moving missile moving at nearly Mach 3 must be considered nuclear until proved otherwise.

That means that they will have NO option but to launch nuclear devices immediately on detection of an incoming missile.

Ok , why do you care Mr Joe Shearer

You are Anyway EMIGRATING ,as you are very sad on BJP's victory

You said this on Pee Dee Eff

🤣🤣
 
Ok , why do you care Mr Joe Shearer

You are Anyway EMIGRATING ,as you are very sad on BJP's victory

You said this on Pee Dee Eff

🤣🤣
Of course I did. And how is that of interest to you? Are you a travel agent? :giggle:
I disagree. 6-7 minutes is not enough time for them to erect their BMs. So they will ALWAYS have to wait that much before launching missile enough for this one to hit.
It isn't about 6 to 7 minutes. Once they learn that something is coming their way, they may go into response mode. How does it matter if their launch takes place eight minutes after detection of our missile, rather than 4?
 
Basically, this one incidence does not change anything. If anything, it adds a doubtful scenario in the minds of decision makers. "Is this lone missile nuclear or like last time it is a blank or conventionally armed one". If anything it makes hair-trigger looser. That is, assuming Pakistani want to live.
The point is that it is unpredictable; it has become unpredictable. Now they have to decide if there is a nuclear warhead on that missile or not. They have to decide and react.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Paro
Now porkis will beg in front of China to donate them radar capable of detecting supersonic missile.
They detected it. They could do nothing in the time available. After ground impact, it was clear that nothing had happened, and it would have been useless firing their own missile.